More thoughts on Targeting and Voluntary Association

by | May 12, 2021 | General Youth Work | 0 comments

Having previously written about targeting I was surprised at the reaction to a recent Tweet. I’ll mention this later, but first let me outline the key points I made in my blog of last October. Remember, this was a time when the government was resisting Marcus Rashford’s attempts to argue weekly food vouchers should be made available to young people in receipt of Free School Meals outside of term-time:

I noted that those voting against the proposal said they weren’t actually opposed to getting kids fed, but rather ‘the system’ of handing out vouchers, as it ‘failed to target those most in need’. My point was that these systems are rarely scrutinised, and it’s even less common to question whether any system is capable of determining precisely who is in need. Furthermore, assuming the existence of a reliable system smacks then of the System World thinking Habermas warned about: surely, ‘a system’ exists?

Hold that thought until I come to ‘targeting’ and ‘referral routes’ later. In contrast, I looked at international examples of assistance that aim to simplify matters. You know what’s coming: these are universal services, which are so often proven to be more effective precisely because they are universal and have the minimum of bureaucracy attached to them. In youth work terms, we are talking of open access provision.

I noted also ‘targeting’ can have a sinister side, describing, as an example, my personal experience of far right intimidation. Worse still, Samuel Paty was targeted.

I concluded by suggesting we need to recognise the logic behind ‘targeting’, where this logic is based on a number of assumptions:

1. There is ‘not enough money’
2. Therefore, ‘we need to get it to those who need it most’
3. A system exists to make these judgements
4. This system is reliable, effective, and fair

Fast forward to this week when I spotted the NYA’s ‘tea-break’ was on the subject of targeting – surely deserved of a spot of group reflective practice, which is what the tea-breaks are sold as.

As ever, after an initial setting of the scene, we were put in breakout groups, where I found to my astonishment that all present were ‘doing targeted work’. Perhaps I shouldn’t have been surprised given, after all, we were there to talk about targeting. But, again, all present were working in contexts where there had been a shift from open access work to targeted work based on referrals from other services. In the plenary thereafter there was similar testimony from the other breakout groups, albeit a few folk spoke up to say they were doing a mixture of things (both open access and targeted youth work). There was though the sense of a consensus that we had lost something here, and that there was not much that could be done about it. Concerns were also expressed about targeting constituting a form of labelling, is something that stigmatises, a rejection of the ethos that ‘everyone’s invited’. Which provoked interesting thoughts about access: if you are not referred are you not welcome? Then there’s the language: “the shift to ‘Early Help / Intervention”; “risk reduction and prevention work”; even “we’ve moved to a social care / social work model – got rid of youth work”, “we’ve seen an end to empowerment work”, “we’re moving away from the old ways”. All seems to be common in youth work’s vernacular these days.

Let me say, I’ve been studying this stuff for years now, and was determined to probe further: “On what basis do young people come to you?” “Poor behaviour at or excluded from school”; “Can’t get on with their mum”; “They’ve been sent to us by the Youth Offending Service.” I’ve heard all this before, but what I’m missing – what I’m really missing – is evidence that folk have gone and checked out the judgements made, and the criteria they are based on? What the hell is being spoken about when a young person is said to have ‘poor behaviour’? You might ask the ex-HMI David Moore about that. I’m afraid to say, in recent years I’ve found almost no evidence of this critique, nor of the, so-called, ‘risk factor prevention paradigm’ (have a go; you’ll be amazed how shaky this is). Sincerely, do this for me: when a young person is referred to you ask about the reasons, the rationale behind the system of identification, the evidence. Please don’t tell me its enough to accept what these ‘professionals’ say.

Compare this with what I am so often told is ‘old school’ practice: whereas no-one in the group I was in had ‘first contact responsibility’, ‘old school’ is welcoming young people into a youth centre, meeting young people on the street during a detached session etc. Whereas one contributor said the idea of ‘relationships’ had been stripped out of their work, ‘old school’ implies a process: initial contact, a mutual desire to engage, care taken in nourishing those relationships, celebrating these relationships becoming established and developing; and keeping an eye on their maintenance. Truly sophisticated practice, where it becomes reasonable to talk of ‘engagement skills’ and the ‘value of relationships’.

The crux of the matter is revealed when it comes to comparing targeted work based on referrals and open access work: how is the relationship formed? To my mind, this is where the elephant enters the room: it’s the issue of ‘voluntary association’. And this is also where the ethics come in. Whenever anyone goes on about ‘the principles of youth work’ you’ll always find reference to voluntary association. So what’s happened? Or perhaps voluntary association doesn’t matter anymore – it’s just ‘old school’?

Well, to me, it does matter; the thing that brought me into youth work was the belief that this was something about power. I wanted to work in a way that celebrated young people’s agency, that facilitated and enhanced their autonomy, that acknowledged that, if this was to happen, I needed to support and create spaces where young people could experience making their own decisions, albeit with the provocation of some challenging questions in their ear. Which is why I always go on about the geography of youth work, as I’ve argued in The Logic of Youth Work, where I locate youth work in civil society contexts, and embrace all that implies.

On this, I can’t tell you what I felt when I came across this quote:

“It is so important that teenagers are able to live elsewhere, in places where they can escape both family constraints and those of the systematic learning of rationale … in truth, it is this participation in social life within frameworks that are relatively free from the family and school sphere that guarantees the gradual emergence of autonomy in adolescence.”

Mérieu, P. (1992) ‘Mais comment peut-on être adolescent ?, Le Ligueur, Bruxelles, le Octobre 2, 1992.

Note: for “the systematic learning of rationale” read ‘school’.

So to my next point (where I could go on about Axel Pohl’s theory of ‘activation’ here – but won’t): implicitly, referral systems externalise needs assessment, young people’s voices rarely get a look in. And, almost always, these needs are constituted as problems. Which then takes us into difficult territory, potentially validating a conceptualisation of the child as someone in deficit, someone who, given circumstances and the behaviours they catalyse, needs fixing. Therein, a long way from an appreciative position, but perhaps that is ‘old school’ too.

For sure some young people have problems, but I want them to tell me about those problems (and their dreams and aspirations) rather than rely on some dodgy risk matrix (or, in future, some dodgy algorithm). Or not tell me; or at least not until they are comfortable in knowing they can hang around without rejection until such time as they are. Here I remember (and will never forget) working with the street-based workers in the Basque country. They talked about ‘The Request’, and their ethic: to be present, accessible, there when people wanted help, to resist telling them what they ‘needed’. They assured me this was not a romantic position, they knew well that their way of working was simply more effective; to push would only drive many away. This is what ‘Low Threshold Practice’ really means.

This can be translated into discussion of motivation. I am interested in young people’s intrinsic motivations and want to resist exerting external pressures (extrinsic motivation). I also want to be careful about banding about descriptors like ‘vulnerable’, to check that I am not, consciously or unconsciously, ‘vulnerablising’ young people, misinterpreting care for control, and confusing ‘risk management’ with what I call ‘at-risk-ism’ – a new form of discrimination.

All said, it’s about time I spoke of that Tweet. It said:

“Seriously, is there anyone left in #youthwork whose work is based on young people’s voluntary association, or is it all referral-based, where we work with those [young people] other sectors have decided have a problem / are problems?”

Of course, I was trying to get a rise, but believe me, I had serious intent: I do think we need to discuss these matters. So I was more than heartened by the many responses, the bulk of which proudly proclaimed they were doing ‘open youth work’ in grassroots, maintained and voluntary settings. Both #Tania de St Croix and Keith Towler (a past Children’s Commissioner of Wales) could see where I was coming from in saying’: “But I recognise / understand why you’ve asked the question. Grassroots open youth work voices can get lost amongst the better funded targeted work.” Frankly, what they are saying is that external agents / funders want us to focus on specific needs; that is, they want to specify young people’s needs.

Others were aware they are on potentially shaky ground when they say they accept referrals “but insist on young people being invited to join instead”, or that ‘they [the young people] can say no’. That is, it begs the question of whether referral from a formal, perhaps judicial, agency can really be rejected by a young person, even if its couched in these terms.

Which takes me to another point not yet mentioned: in targeting we appear to be accepting the individuation of our practice. Invariably, we are talking about individuals here, individual referrals, and perhaps then forget the social context of youth (and community) work. This gives me another opportunity to dine out on this, which is broadly my experience (I’ll leave you to do an analysis of this history of youth work and its trajectory / implications):

• Community Worker >
• Community Education Worker >
• Community Development Worker >
• Community & Youth Worker >
• Youth & Community Worker >
• Youth Worker >
• Youth Support Worker >
• Targeted Youth Support Worker

So, in closing, let me be clear (and as I said in a response to a Tweet): I know only too well, from years of experience, that there is still plenty of grassroots, open, voluntary youth work going on. And I celebrate that. But, I asked: “what of the trajectory; are we experiencing a significant shift in the conceptualisation of #youthwork, the death throes of voluntary association?” Which solicited the response “voluntary engagement is essential or it isn’t youth work!”

It would be easy to stop there, and applaud; but this conceptual point hangs in the air: if targeting is what we do, and are seen to do, and what we talk about, it is unsurprising that others will perceive that is what youth work is. And we already know this is where the policy meisters are running with this. Can then these more democratic meanings be made clear? I was intrigued by responses that suggested ‘the tide was turning’ and there was a renewed interest in open access work, including from funders. I’d love to hear more about that. To some degree, I’m on the same page, having viewed the experience of youth work (especially detached youth work) during the pandemic as peculiarly positive, where workers were engaged much more in what I would call ‘community-based youth work’, focussing on the needs presented by young people, largely abandoning ‘outcomes-driven work’. I explored these ideas in a recent presentation to workers in South Wales, where, as ever, I was keen to argue that our work doesn’t get consumed by interventions that merely help young people and wider communities ‘cope’ with the issues they face. So, when it comes to ‘meeting needs’ it is essential to address the question of what we can do to both draw attention to the causes of these needs and what we can do to truly act upon them – to push back on / remove these causes. Which means keeping alive the discourse on inequalities and social justice. I hope that doesn’t sound too ‘old school’.

The last word has to go to detached youth work which, as ever, shines a light on core youth work principles, and reminds us that youth work is a practice based in civil society, where voluntary association is intrinsic to that reality. And where targeting is done on the basis of geography, where we work in the most underserved areas, with young people, and those wider communities. It’s a while ago now but I remember wrestling with some of these ideas when I wrote ‘Reconnecting Detached Youth Work’ where I tried to have my cake and eat it, in speaking of ‘targeting through universalism’. In this, youth workers are accessible to all and, through our engagement, and as a product of young people’s requests, there are those in the group whom we’ll seek to invest more time and resources in, secure in the knowledge that we are not labelling them or stigmatising them, that what happens is a product of voluntary and mutual association, and is all the better and more effective for it.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *