The Logic of Youth Work

by | Sep 15, 2020 | General Youth Work | 0 comments

Youth work takes place in civil society. Yes, youth work methodologies might be used in formal (institutional) settings, like school, but that doesn’t make what’s happening youth work. Fundamentally, youth work takes place in informal environments, where young people choose to be, free from the compulsion commonly associated with formal settings. Likewise, youth work does not take place in the home, where – just as with school – adults tend to ‘rule the roost’. To be precise then, youth work takes place in another (I hesitate to say ‘third ’) space that they have some control over, and it’s this space, and its value, that defines youth work. Succinctly: “It is so important that teenagers are able to live elsewhere, in places where they can escape both family constraints and those of the systematic learning of rationale …” (Mérieu, 1992).

This is space where people, whether young or old, come together for the principal reason of being social. Its significance cannot be underestimated, particularly for educators (which I assume to be the primary identity of youth workers) and for those for whom autonomy is the primary aim of [that] education. We should note: few, if any, educators (whether working in formal or informal settings) contest this philosophy.

Accordingly, “in truth, it is this participation in social life within frameworks that are relatively free from the family and school sphere that guarantees the gradual emergence of autonomy in adolescence.” (ibid.).

This geographical reality then informs a further logic: youth work is defined by voluntary association; young people are free to come and go. The educator has no power – beyond their moral authority – to insist on a time of arrival, or departure, or, for that matter, the participation of young people in ‘what’s organised’. Young people decide; their presence is dictated by their intrinsic motivation. If they don’t like it they walk.

Therein, logic now demands the youth worker appreciate the ethical implications of seeking to employ extrinsic pressures, as if to over-ride the young person’s intrinsic motivation. While it is difficult to argue against the value of encouragement, as soon as there is talk of ‘incentivisation’, or contractualism, or the like, they are on dodgy ground. Thereafter, other strategies to secure participation are even more likely to be manipulative, which is beyond the pale ethically. In sum, nothing can be demanded of young people under threat of sanction etc.

What’s left?

Only the power of that encouragement, and only the power of democratic processes, such as dialogue and negotiation.

The practice then becomes defined by the messy ground of wants and needs, and, fundamentally, the argument as to who decides what those needs are. There is no disputing a want; we might even ascribe it an ‘expressed need’. And it’s reasonable to say we might not know what our needs are. So, to repeat, who determines needs per se is really the crux of the matter. Few commentators, whether parents or carers, teachers, social workers, or policy makers can resist saying what they think young people need. Nor should they. But what sets them apart from youth workers is they assume the validity and authority of their contexts. The youth worker, for the reasons of geography cum informality given, cannot. Which is not to say their views as to young people’s needs don’t matter; they do. But the difference is that they have to work in a space where their views are only part of the story. The rest of the story is, necessarily, authored by young people.

We see now the logic of practice demands a meeting of minds, which can only ever be agreed upon in the rough and tumble of argumentation. Without such agreement (an agreement founded on young people’s intrinsic motivation) the job’s off.

Now, there are those in the mix who presume authority, most notably (in this day and age) funders. They want their pound of flesh, or (to put it more sympathetically) they too have a view as to what young people need. And, reasonably enough, they are prepared to pay for it. Naturally, to them, the youth worker who can ‘deliver’ is valued. But maybe they are missing something? Or, perhaps they don’t care if the means used to secure the outcomes they desire are unethical. Or, perhaps they’re not even aware of this logic of participation.

Therein the absurd – illogical – nature of outcomes-prescribed youth work. If needs are determined in advance of a dialogue between young people and youth workers this is not youth work. And if this was the start of a process, so too what follows (everything that comes after) must be informed by the ebb and flow of daily negotiation; everything in the name of the pursuit of endeavours that aim at meeting those needs must be subject to this negotiation. Respect for young people’s intrinsic motivation is essential throughout. Ultimately, the only logical, reasonable, authentic, and ethical conclusion is that ‘outcomes are what comes out’: we’ll see.

A final thought.

In his wonderful little books ‘The Digested Read’ (volumes one and two, and in years’ worth of Guardian articles) John Crace takes a series of longer stories and ‘digests’ them into 500 words or so. And for those for whom a digested read is too much, he provides the ‘digested read, digested’, which is little more than a sentence. In much the same way, if you want a single word that defines youth work, logic dictates this word is participation, where participation is “The principle that those who will be substantially affected by decisions made by social and political institutions must be involved in the making of those decisions.” (EEC, 1977). Without it, it’s not youth work.

References

EEC, as quoted in Bullock, A., Stallybrass, O. & Trombley, S. (eds.) (1977) Fontana Dictionary of Modern Thought, London: Fontana Press, p. 458.

Crace, J. (2005/2006) The Digested Read Vols. 1 & 2, Guardian Newspapers: London.

Mérieu, P. (1992) ‘Mais comment peut-on être adolescent?’, Le Ligueur, Bruxelles, le Octobre 2, 1992, pp. 1-5.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *