Word of the Week? ‘Targeting’.

by | Oct 26, 2020 | Social Commentary | 0 comments

I’m an avid reader of Stephen Poole’s ‘Word of the Week’, in which he writes a few lines about a word, or phrase, that achieved prominence at that time. Recently, we’ve been treated to ‘The Measures’, ‘exponentially’, ‘herd immunity’, and ‘Tiers’ (all references to the language used by government in its articulation of COVID-19 policy, although there are plenty of others in his back catalogue).

Poole has got me in the habit of thinking about my word of the week. Usually, several come to mind, but this week I’m in no doubt: it has to be ‘targeting’, which has come up in very many of the most high profile news stories.

I made a point of switching on BBC Parliament [starts 2.59] to listen to the entirety of the Opposition Day Debate on Free School Meals, even though this was somewhat erroneously labelled – given the issue at hand was getting disadvantaged children fed during this half-term, and the forthcoming Christmas and Easter school holidays.

It’s probably not well known that this is a topic that parliament has spent a good deal of time discussing, but there can be few unaware of Marcus Rashford’s intervention and success in lobbying the government to provide weekly food vouchers last summer to children in receipt of free school meals during term-time. This week he was simply seeking an extension to that scheme, but the vote was lost with just 5 Tories rebelling.  It was detail of the arguments that I found most interesting; one after another those opposing the specific proposal lined up to argue that they weren’t actually opposed to getting kids fed but rather the system of handing out vouchers. Almost without exception, we were told this was not the way to ‘target’ those most in need. I have long since been fascinated by the use of this word, not so much in terms of the concept, but rather what lays behind it. I’m referring here to a presumption rarely talked about – that a system exists capable of determining precisely who should be targeted. It’s also implied (but again rarely discussed), that such a system is value-based: that it is rigorous and fair. When it comes to Free School Meals (FSM) the criteria that activates them is being in receipt of a range of existing benefits, broadly speaking those designed to alleviate poverty. As such, FSM is pretty much always treated as a proxy metric for poverty.

A central issue for those voting against is that the system is ripe for abuse. They seem confident that actually handing over a meal to a pupil at school works, but worry more that a voucher system can be corrupted. Indeed, we heard tales of vouchers being traded for drugs, including in crack dens, and for sex in brothels.

Stripped bare, these ‘concerns’ appear to provide an insight into how the humanity of the families in question are conceptualised. Even when the commentator recognises that what they are saying pertains to only “a minority of families”, the suggestion is that we need to guard against fecklessness: it’s the old trope about the undeserving poor.

Years ago I looked at examples rooted in different ideological positions, that basically took the view that it is reasonable to trust people. Brasil’s Bolsa Familia demonstrated that simply handing over a few extra quid a week had a profound effect on children’s welfare; poor parents overwhelming demonstrated their ability to use very modest amounts of money very wisely, such was their experience of having learned to do so. But it was the contextual background to this scheme that was most intriguing; corruption was rife, and it became obvious that creating a new bureaucracy to administer the targeting of the grant would likely lead to a good deal of the money never getting to the families; ‘targeting’ and ‘systems’ were judged a barrier to effectiveness.

Targeting has also become an issue in relation to voters, whether during the Brexit referendum, or over the pond in both the last and forthcoming presidential elections, the lid has been lifted on the shady practices of targeted social media. Such is the ability of these systems to track social media use, and turn this data into predictive algorithms, lobbyists now believe they can identify individuals who are ‘on side’, or ‘persuadable’ – both in terms of voting for a particular candidate or not voting at all (what has become known as ‘voter suppression’).

In France, teacher Samuel Paty was targeted, and murdered, by an Islamist extremist, influenced, again, by those abusing social media. I have a related experience; a photo of me was once posted on the home page of Red Watch, the image taken whilst I was demonstrating against a far right protest in my community. Targeting, in this sense, can make the hair stand up on the back of your neck; believe me.

If we were to take these examples together, we might conclude targeting is often employed for malicious purposes. But what are the alternatives? One is to seek an extension of, so-called, ‘universal services’, they are the logical opposite, yes? But isn’t this just replacing one ideology with another? Perhaps then we might do well to think a little more about the detail of all this. A starting point is to recognise the obvious; that when we say: “we need to target” this immediately shifts the discussion away from universal services. Those making these claims tend to employ a rider; they say: “money is scarce, so we need to get it to those who need it most.” Which few would argue with, until, that is, we explore the assumptions made.

  • Is money scarce?
  • Do we know who needs it most (which, again, seems to suggest only some of the needy should be helped)?
  • And a systemic question (in terms of knowing who needs it most): do we have a capable and reliable system for deciding that?

Put simply, the proposition presumes the existence of such a system.

In conclusion, we see that when we take even a modest amount of time to problematise these realities a whole series of issues, and important questions, are revealed – questions rarely examined.

Perhaps then it does make sense to consider universal services, freed as they are from many of these assumptions.

This kind of thinking can get us to new places, or at least places that might become obvious, provided that is we are prepared to explore the ‘taken for granted’. Consider youth work, where the narrative of ‘targeting’ has come to dominate its recent past, and sits in tension with an historical commitment to ‘open access’ work – making services accessible to all. And yet, what we’ve seen from youth workers is a desire to think both critically and creatively: to commit to a community-based model that all young people can engage with (in part at least to avoid the stigmatisation so often associated with targeting), and to articulate the fact that it’s easier said than done to target someone. This alludes to the realities of working in a civil society context, where voluntary association is intrinsic to that reality – if young people don’t want to engage they are not going to engage.  Policy-makers so often seem oblivious to this fact.

The upshot of all this is what’s needed is a practice that I have described as ‘targeting through universalism’. It is not without a caveat: what we know, and what we are proud of, is that we do want to target – not individuals but underserved communities. I can only hope that when the government talks about ‘levelling up’ this is what it look like.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *