The central characters in BBC 1’s recent crime drama Blue Lights are three police recruits; two are easily identifiable as ‘young people’. The challenges they face including engaging with those of a similar age, many of whom hold a deep antipathy toward the police. The third episode, Fear is of particular interest to observers of youth in society as it involves a ‘punishment shooting’ of a young man. Courageously, the third, older, recruit (previously a social worker) challenges a senior officer using this term telling him that, officially, he should refer to what’s happened as a ‘paramilitary-style attack’. The logic, she has to explain, is that referring to such attacks as ‘punishment’ “implies the victim deserves it.” And this could never be the case for “a 15 year-old kid”.
I don’t know if ‘Fear’ was purposefully aired on the 25th anniversary of the signing of the Good Friday Agreement, an event that Rishi Sunak said required “bravery, perseverance and political imagination”, but I’m sure the images of police vehicles being attacked by groups of masked young people, some not yet teenagers, couldn’t have been foreseen. In tandem with Republican parades, to mark the anniversary of the 1916 Easter Uprising against British Rule in Ireland, the BBC broadcast images of petrol bombs being thrown at a police Land Rover in the Creggan area of Derry. Their correspondent Emma Vardy spoke of “planned and orchestrated street disorder” (without saying who did the planning and orchestrating) and asserted it was young people who had been “tasked with carrying out these actions”. And in an interaction with one young man we hear him say “It’s just another day for me; just a day to go out and hit cops.” Whilst referencing the marches, he is clear that “As long as the cops get hit that’s all that matters.” Worryingly, Vardy’s interpretation is of this being “clearly a bit of fun for some people.” And there’s “definitely no fear of getting in trouble.” She concludes her news item with something more thoughtful “The past can still be used to fan the flames of conflict for the, so-called, Peace Generation.” (So-called, that is, as it refers to those born since the Good Friday Agreement was signed; which reminds us we are talking about young people here.)
So, for those working with and for young people, we might ask: ‘what is happening here?’ Social media commentary about the event is valuable in directing us to questions the mainstream media failed to ask – questions that surely need to be asked, and questions those working with and for young people have a responsibility to ask. Foremost these were about safeguarding; with obvious knowledge and experience of the local context, @phairycakes asked “Who is delivering these crates of ready-made petrol bombs?” and “What are these children and young people being offered in exchange for rioting?” The point is to see this as child criminal exploitation in which young people are actively “groomed, coerced, recruited and radicalised” by “paramilitary gangs”. For another commentator “this is what modern slavery looks like in Northern Ireland.” We can be thankful that Contextual Safeguarding has emerged as a means to think widely about harm and, especially, the multiple (rather than singular) origins of these harms. And (similarly) multiple responses to these harms. Others asked the deepest of questions: “What kind of Ireland is this built on?” And what kind of administration thinks it reasonable to cut so grievously “the front–line youth services many young people rely on; is this a consequence of those decisions?”
From whatever perspective, it’s clear that what’s happening demands action on the part of all concerned. Not that this is easy; as the story line in Blue Lights makes abundantly clear: there’s a history of silence in the face of paramilitary threats to overcome.
All this reveals a further substantive issue: the capacity those working with and for young people have to respond to these issues depends as much on how their work is conceptualised (whether by policy makers, employers, the wider community or, indeed, workers themselves) as the resources available to them. Which is why the footage of young people throwing petrol bombs constitutes also an extraordinary provocation: a provocation that, in the case of youth work, demands: ‘How do you see the world of work with young people?’; ‘What kind of a youth worker are you?’ And, accordingly, ‘In what terms do you identify as a youth worker?’
What’s revealed is the troubling notion of youth work as a ‘floating concept’; the idea that the term ‘youth work’ is now so amorphous it can mean anything and everything to each and everyone, reducible to simply ‘working with’ young people (with scant regard for the fact that teachers work with young people, as do social workers, police officers and GPs). The need for definitional clarity is obvious. To some youth work sits in a leisure and recreation context, where diversion from negative behaviours is considered a laudable aim. To others youth work constitutes a “progressive response to crime”, which is problematic too as this implies aims are shaped not by young people’s needs (as they perceive them) but rather the needs of others; in this case, those whose express intent it is to reduce the incidence of anti-social behaviour and crime – end of. This makes the practice data-led (specifically police data-led) and, as such, it is diminished in its response to young people’s expressed needs.
Taking on these conceptual challenges is useful; paradigmatic issues are revealed, not least how behaviouralism and psychological understandings of the world have come to dominate the youth work discourse. Which, in turn, has influenced a plethora of youth work responses, from the provision of ‘diversionary activities’ and training for young people in ‘anger management’, to specialist ‘violence interruption’, and a range of explicitly therapeutic interventions that encompass ‘trauma’ and ‘shame’-informed practices.
None of these can be judged without value, but they all have something deeply problematic in common: they represents a ‘flight from the social’ – the onward march of a process of individuation, where practice focuses its attention not on groups or communities or political structures but specific ‘target’ individuals. Indeed, the mantra of ‘targeting’ is now all-pervading. And the influence of ideology plain to see; targeting is rationalised as necessary, a more effective use of ‘limited resources’ (which are assumed and conveniently (for some) obviate discussion of resource allocation in the first place). This ideological capture is bolstered by demands to monitor and evaluate practice as if youth work is a technical system; the obsession with quantification drowns out most, sometimes all, qualitative perspectives. This is the work of men with sharp swords. They demand also evidence of prevention, without regard for the basic philosophical question as to whether the absence of something can be specifically attributed to something that went before. For sure there are those who express confidence in doing so, but the problem here is that validating such claims demands a baseline position, a system of benchmarking (‘targeted’) young people on the basis of past crimes, and showing they haven’t transgressed since. Or (in the absence of past crimes) validation is secured only through a particular theorisation of ‘risk’ and adoption of the even more problematic discourse of young people ‘at risk’. Which assumes ‘evidence’ of an individual’s propensity to commit crime – in the future – on the basis of who they are / their circumstances now (with all the potential for discrimination that involves).
It become obvious then that policy agendas influence youth work practices that are increasingly disconnected from social phenomena, whether social harms or the effects of discriminatory systems and structures; political analysis is made redundant. Which is precisely why what happened in Derry is so telling; if ever there was a case where it is so patently clear that youth workers need to engage with the wider social and political context it is this. Otherwise we are left only with an analysis that roots the problematic behaviours of young people solely in them as individuals, which only gives voice to the many other commentators that, especially through social media, would have it that the cause of all this is, quite simply, evil. Reductive political narratives both nourish and feed off this, fostering division, intent as they are on diversion from the fundamental issue of inequality.
Perhaps Blue Lights can show us the way; for the social work influenced officer, bred perhaps to see things through a social rather than individual lens, the profound influence of the drugs trade and its violent dealers on young people is unquestionable. Likewise the consequences of Northern Ireland having a higher level of multiple deprivation than any other region in the rest of the UK, with over a third of the population living on or below the breadline. And this in a wider, UK-wide, context of growing inequality accelerated by the politics of austerity. Another recruit has a criminology degree and uses (surreptitiously – for fear of getting caught) the crime mapping tools he had learned at college to expose the willful blindness of senior officers to paramilitary activities. It’s worth noting geographers also use mapping as a research methodology and increasing numbers of youth workers (especially detached youth workers) are employing them in their work.
What of other disciplinary perspectives that might also prove useful in resisting the dominance of psychology? How about philosophy? In a past blog I explored the potential of practical philosophy and critical thinking as educative responses to radicalisation and describe work I’d done using these methodologies in youth work both directly with young people but also in the form of facilitation training for youth workers. Such skills and the use of Community of Inquiry methodologies are in evidence in the award-winning film Young Plato which is located in the Ardoyne area of Belfast and engages with issues similar to those in Blue Lights. See also Community Philosophy.
This too informs some of the thinking needed if youth workers are to engage successfully, productively and confidently with these and the many other sensitive, controversial and challenging issues they come into contact with. Certainly, they need to be well-versed in the historical complexity behind many of these issues, as part of their research. And prepared to analyse what’s happening from a range of disciplinary perspectives, to which we might add peace work. It is no coincidence that there is a wealth of expertise of peace-oriented youth work in Northern Ireland.
The fact that many of these perspectives emphasise social dynamics makes possible the re-socialisation of youth work, and a more robust engagement with social, political and democratic contexts. The case of Northern Ireland is illustrative; it should teach all youth workers, regardless of where they are working, that with bravery, perseverance and political imagination opportunities exist to do ever more meaningful and transformative youth work … provided, that is, they resist the flight from the social. All would do well to watch Blue Lights and actively respond, wherever they work, to its provocation: ‘What should youth work be doing here?’
Note: The 2023 Federation for Detached Youth Work annual conference, scheduled for November, will address many of these themes.
0 Comments