For all its faults, might the Prevent Agenda, constitute an opportunity to advance democratic education?

by | Dec 6, 2018 | Democracy | 0 comments

Often, I look on aghast at what’s happening in the name of education, and especially its apparent transformation into an instrumentalised and technical endeavour, focussed, it seems, more on securing exam grades than something more holistic, including, for me at least, a nod to the democratic.

With a lad who has recently started at a sixth form college, I was heartened to hear the Principal, in the first words of an opening address to new parents, assert: “This is not an exam factory.” And yet, by the end of it, my anger had returned, as my thoughts turned to ‘why does this even have to be said?’

Of course, this debate has been long-running, and is not without its controversies. Being seen as having a dig at schools that secure good exam results is not going to win many friends. So one ends up casting around for spaces and places where there might be some hope for democratic education. What of philosophy for children, or P4C as its known; might it be making some progress? At the recent annual conference of Sapere I was struck by the enthusiasm for bringing philosophical enquiry into the classroom, but, again, deflated by the multiple references to the difficulties in “fitting it in”; and the constraints of a “packed timetable”. Clearly, the primary purpose of school seems to be something else. Elsewhere, democratic activities are forms of ‘enrichment’; activities undertaken when the real business of schooling is over. Odd though that we don’t seek to ‘enrich’ everything in school. It’s rare then that P4C is regarded as much more than an ‘added extra’. But what of the mandatory; the things schools are expected to do, that the powers that be insist upon. Religious Education is an interesting one. In recent times we witnessed a growth in its popularity amongst students. Not, it seems, because of any particular passion for religion, but, simply, because it represented a space, a time, when students could do what they always seem desperate to do: explore ideas; argue about values, and in a conversational way – through dialogue: which would seem to be the essence of the practice of democratic education. RE, for many students, constituted the only opportunity to do this. Terrible then that further ‘pressures’ have led to a situation where it’s often now offered as a 0.5 GCSE rather than a whole one. Worse still, RE has, in so many institutions, been superseded by RS, Religious Studies: a taught, knowledge-based, subject, rather than one taught through dialogue.

Other statutory duties include the Prevent Agenda. Herein, there have been criticisms a plenty, which I have no wish to reiterate or gloss over. Rather, I’m interested in related pedagogies. There have always been educators who sense an opportunity in the controversial, but, in the main, many express fears about working with (more generally) ‘challenging conversations’. Which does seem to suggest the teaching of the skills necessary to facilitate dialogue, especially on sensitive and controversial topics, is really important … and rare. But a deeper analysis reveals many educators fear not just the issues that might come up but surveillance: not just of their own dealings with these matters but the perception that they are being asked to undertake the surveillance of others. Haynes & Passey express concerns that this leads to a situation where both teachers and students self-censor, avoid speaking about topics that may be deemed to attract a ‘red flag’. Therein, the perverse situation where there is less dialogue, not more, and the practice of democracy withers before it even gets started.

Prompted by this, and influenced by work in the Nordic countries, I have tried to find an accommodation within this undoubtedly problematic agenda; which has not been easy as I’ve resisted and critiqued it for a good while. This is the stuff of ‘democratic competencies’, a narrative at the heart of the Norwegian government’s response to the Brevik atrocity; rather than opt for a protection-oriented regime they resolved to “thrown even more resources at democracy”, an appreciative stance involving particularly the further creation of opportunities for young people to learn through the practice of it. Lest we forget the young people targeted on the island of Utoya were doing exactly that, coming together to learn about politics and democracy though debate and dialogue.

Charlie Hebdo followed and my thoughts turned again to process and pedagogy. It did strike me there was a terrible irony in the narrative of teaching ‘Fundamental British Values’ as a response to extremist threats. I speculated what was needed was a re-imagination of how best to do this.

What’s interesting is this practice – the practice of democratic education – need not take as its subject the heady world of radicalisation, extremism and terrorism; rather a broader emphasis on critical thinking is needed. Hence, we can, and perhaps should, be approaching these threats more generally. For example, I had fun discussing a story about a polar bear turning up on a Scottish island with young people. It was presented merely as a stimulus for discussion, without reference to ‘Fake News’. I was struck by how quickly those present split into opposing camps and were determined to hold their position. Being distanced from the experience of argument and contestation only seems to fuel these polarities. It wasn’t until I invited all present to consult their smart phones (something that many educators might rail against but nonetheless connects immediately to a world of digital nativism many older can’t comprehend) that anything remotely democratic occurred. We discussed how far and for how long polar bears can swim, and the extent of travel of fractured ice sheets (on which we were told the polar bear was transported). Hardly the stuff of in-depth science but at least we were questioning, enquiring, discussing evidence. Once the penny dropped this was an April Fool, the discussion turned to how ‘facts and figures’ can be presented to us in manipulated ways, and how it’s easy to be hoodwinked. It was hardly radical in the big scheme of things to conclude that it was important to ‘check stuff out’, but for these young people it actually was.

I’m minded by how important it is, as the controversial comedian Sarah Silverman says, of ‘liking having one’s mind changed’. Silverman is perhaps an unlikely advocate of Socratic values, but no less important for that. She advocates inhabiting the spaces ‘the kids want to be’ – principally, the internet and social media; and offers a perspective those committed to combating extremism might usefully engage with:

“As a comedian, trolls to me, I see them as hecklers. And what I’ve come to learn about hecklers is, whatever they’re yelling out, the subtext is: ‘I exist!’ Right? And that’s what I see on the internet. They want love. They go towards love. That’s why people join hate groups. They find family there. They find acceptance there. That’s why Trump has gone to the far right. People there go: ‘You’re amazing!’ They like him there. They see they can manipulate him with love. Our governments are filled with people with daddy issues who don’t look inward, who have no perspective, who don’t live examined lives, and we’re all paying for it. You see that in trolls and in the rage on the internet. This is misplaced anger!”

In considering the means of manipulation, I’ve become fascinated with a theme that often emerges in my discussions with young people: so often we end up discussing ‘likelihood’. Or, in other words, probability, and, dare I say it: risk, which, for the life of me, is an abused concept these days.

Reading Michael Blastland and David Spiegelhalter’s wonderful The Norm Chronicles has helped me appreciate that the teaching of probability (and risk) is needed not just for maths. It has a wide and, I’d say, increasingly important, social value. Their mission is no less than: “to start – or restart – reflection on that mighty clash of world-views”. A big ask. Which is to suggest that the challenge of advancing democratic education is great, and embedded not just in institutions but the broader ideological and policy-making apparatus that shape what these institutions do, but also wider social realities.

At risk of being manipulated by ‘click-bait’, I read the article: Millennials: the age of entitlement. Vieno Vehko’s (a pseudonymous assistant professor at a Midwestern university in America) portrait undoubtedly created a stir. Notwithstanding the obvious and reasonable criticism that older generations have always had it in for the youth, since the days of the Ancient Greeks (and probably even before), my guess is there’s more than a few folk working in education who can relate to at least some of what’s described; things certainly ain’t rosy. Criticism of my position accepted. So its an incredibly mixed picture, of young people’s desires to engage in democracy and a range of influence that inhibit it.

We are left then with the recognition that advancing ‘the democratic project’ is going to take a whole lot of work, not just in the institutions whose responsibility it is to educate young and old, but in the myriad spaces that constitute civil society at large. Indeed, as Aislinn O’Donnell argues, we might need to think more broadly of ‘public education’ if we are to defend and make progress with a project that is not only being questioned but attacked.

Maybe, such work in non-institutional, community, spaces (to-date, relatively free of the gaze of surveillance experienced elsewhere) may now be vital. We have to find spaces and places to take, as O’Donnell says, ‘the beautiful risk of education’. Which might remind us of the significance of probability, and implicitly the value of uncertainty. And the essential relationship between uncertainty and democracy: a point made by Dewey, deep in the bowels of a rarely visited page in his seminal work on Democracy and Education: “If there are genuine uncertainties in life, philosophies must reflect that uncertainty.” With this we might conclude education and the philosophies that guide it has and needs to be an uncertainty-appreciative practice, particularly if it is to equip young people for the world in which we all now live.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *