There you have it, or at least someone notable to bear witness to the devastation being inflicted on youth work by the coalition’s cuts. Polly Toynbee’s withering critique of the impact of austerity on the Salmon Youth Centre in Bermondsey, London, should enrage anyone with a conscience. The prospect of a country without decent youth services is as grave as one without libraries; the very heart and soul of civic society ripped from communities too often disadvantaged in the first place. And it’s the cheapest of shots to say that volunteers can take up the slack. There are countless in the youth service anyway, but where is the recognition of the importance of those professionally trained who catalyse and act as the glue sticking these volunteers together? Do Messrs. Cameron, Clegg, Pickles and Gove think I was having a laugh investing in what now adds up to more than the equivalent of five years full-time study in order to be a youth and community worker?
Perhaps, the Youth Service now falls foul of its historical failure to secure statutory status. But this has always been a moot point, as many believe in its Big Society and community-based foundations. How ironic is that? Trying to square this circle, and not without criticism, I have spent years arguing that youth work needed to claim more vociferously its educational status. Had it done so, perhaps the funding might have held up a little more. Likewise, it allowed itself to be subsumed into a problem-fixing policy narrative rather than articulate itself in a positive, developmental, way. Too many in the service have gone along with this for short-term financial gain. Seeing youth work as about learning rather than diversion and therapy makes me loathe to speak of social fall out or a wider ‘social deficit’, as Toynbee puts it. But there seems something inevitable about this, and the likely costs to other services, like policing and health, as a consequence.
It may be that the lack of these and other community-based services might usher in a more enlightened era in which we value more the kind of things (to paraphrase Toynbee again) that are difficult to prove the value of through statistics. And it might bring youth work a profile that, to-date, it has failed to secure. Ultimately it might beg an eternal question; why are teachers, police officers, health care workers and so on, a permanent presence in our communities – and youth and community workers not?
0 Comments