Thoughts on the value of human presence

by | May 31, 2020 | Philosophy | 0 comments

COVID19 has changed lots of things for lots of people. And so too is it for those who work with people. It is unsurprising then to read the likes of: “Coronavirus will change the way adult care is managed in Leeds after staff have been forced to find new ways of working, say social workers” (Emma Ryan, How pandemic changed social work for the better). I propose instead a sceptical position; we should be careful in assuming the ‘new normal’ is already cast in stone.

Looking closely, we see there is more than one proposition here, and neither is peculiar to social work. Taking the latter first, it seems indisputable that almost every form of ‘people work’ has had to find new ways of working in response to the risks associated with COVID19. But the former – the suggestion that Coronavirus will change the form and function of social work (or any other social practice for that matter) in the future – seems very presumptive. I say this because the temporality of each proposition matters greatly. We may indeed have observed social workers working in new ways in response to COVID19: that is something we can say about what’s happened – the past. But saying social work practice, and the management of it, will change is future-oriented, speculative, a ‘may be’ at best. Despite the efforts of humans for thousands of years, we have never been able to make judgements on the future with certainty, and this is especially so in the human sciences. And if we needed any reminder that the future is uncertain, we have the very reality we’re living now, a reality that just a few months ago was pretty much unimaginable.  So, in the absence of a definitive evidence-base, we’re left with what Snoopy used to say in response to all questions: “It depends”. And it’s this I want to explore here.

The newspaper article I mention above describes a tribunal (in relation to a person detained under the Mental Health Act) being conducted via Skype, and home visits now being done by three way phone and video calls. We are told, “in lockdown we can’t get to see everyone face to face” and, in the same breath, “video calls have been so important to have that face to face contact”. What’s missing here is any explicit statement about what constitutes ‘face to face’. We might infer ‘seeing someone face to face’ implies being in physical proximity to them. And yet a video call seems to constitute face to face contact also. Does it? Notionally yes, I suppose, but the question is: does physical proximity (or the lack of it) matter? I suspect it becomes a question of value or, more pertinently, values.

The article also contains, I acknowledge, an example of a social worker going out to see someone despite lockdown and despite the risks. But this is a crisis intervention where paramedics had to assist. Clearly here the value of physical proximity trumps the lack of it. Ultimately, we are told: “the Coronavirus situation has forced the social care department to break with the norm and it is unlikely to go back [my emphasis]”, which seems to consolidate my point that the future appears (for some at least) to have already been written, cast in stone. To my mind, all this seems a little premature, can it be true that we’ve already thought through these questions of value? If not, let me weigh in with a few thoughts of my own.

As a starter, the question of whether we go back to proximity-based work seems to depend to a significant degree on whether we’re told to. I’ll come to the question of whether we can influence these decisions later. But for now, let me suggest very much depends on how decision-makers (whoever they are) conceptualise ‘people work’, and especially now in the light of COVID19. And when I say ‘conceptualise’ I mean both in terms of meaning and value. One hopes too that there’s some reflection on history. Take, for example, the debacle associated with moving much of the work of probation officers online. And it’s not like teaching lacks prior ‘virtual’ experience; we’ve had MOOCs (Mass Open Online Courses) for a while now. What depends also is how aims are conceptualised. If, for example, we see teaching as knowledge transmission little could be said against shifting the lot online, as some already propose: Cambridge University students will be taught entirely online until at least the summer of 2021 . Doubtless others will follow. And yet, there’s already a backlash from students; what are we paying for they ask? Many clearly believe they are paying for a proximity-based experience. Some of course refer to the lack of access to science labs, and opportunity to do experiments, rather than observe someone else doing them, online. But in the main, they are valuing highly the social aspects of their university education as much as the academic teaching. In fact, they see the two as intertwined; they think it’s important that they are taught face to face, by teachers (in the flesh). And that they can discuss their learning, directly, with those teachers and fellow students. Does a class analysis help? Well, I for one am not surprised that one of the wealthiest universities is the first to say they will opt for online learning on an extended basis, as wealth tends to value academia above the social and pastoral aspects of learning. Discuss.

How about looking at it from the practitioners’ point of view? In the article above, we are told “social care teams have been using technology to keep in touch with people and keep the system working – and say in many ways it is working better”. Clearly some are already on board with these ideas. What of teachers? Some of them point to the value of virtual learning in making education more flexible (and therefore accessible) and equitable (which tends to follow on). But to say that in many ways the virtual is better is to suggest physical proximity is less or not important.

Perhaps the detail is important; in which case we need to ask: what, precisely, is working better, and what is not? In the context of COVID19, it might be as simple as saying some contact is better than no contact. But what’s at issue in the commentary I’ve referenced is not now, it’s the future, where we anticipate the constraints we are currently experiencing will go away. Will, then, digital technologies be valued in the same way? Again, it seems to depend on our values. Some might be attracted to economic values; if all social work, and teaching, was done on line it would certainly be cheaper. And all those buildings could be re-purposed or flogged off to recoup at least some of the money spent on dealing with COVID19. If that sounds like an exaggerated proposition, we can be sure there are some finance managers happy we are working from home, and paying for the desk, the technology, the broadband, and so on. Granted, some employers are more sympathetic, and recognise this personal investment. And then there are other costs. I know of one university who have reduced the amount of hours they expect staff to work by 10% now staff are working from home. This is to take account of the fact that the working day doesn’t now involve periods of downtime, like simply moving from one meeting to another. Put another way, online working is pretty exhausting; who really is able to engage fully when the day involves one Zoom meeting after another? Or is it? In contrast, I was asked to sit in on a national organisation’s managers’ meeting recently, to contribute a guest speaker perspective toward the end. I had the unusual experience of being an observer for all but the last ten minutes. And I can say that of the 40 or so participants, the vast majority said nothing, and contributed nothing to the chat function. The cynic in me thinks some have worked out what the camera on/off button is for – as a means to go off and make a cup of tea. I’m stretching a point I know, particularly as we’ve never really been able to assume folk are engaged even when they’re physically present.

There are plenty of other and related questions, and assumptions to explore. Do teachers own what they teach; are the video recordings of their lessons and lectures theirs’; or can they be reused by their employers for future generations of students, including as a means to push back during industrial disputes – as a way of breaking strikes? What about audience; if teaching moves online who is watching; might employers use it as a form of surveillance? On this, how eerie is it that one of the most common online teaching tools is called Panopto? Then there is the potential for surveillance by hate groups. In America, Alt Right groups are monitoring online teaching to identify ‘liberal’ educators and those contesting the hate speech of others, with malicious intent. I’ve looked back at some of the speeches I’ve given, and I can see now I have said things, many things, that might upset others, and that’s not just the ‘lunatic fringe’. Of course, we’re not immune from push back when we express our opinions in proximity with others, but it does seem reasonable to say many folk wouldn’t say the things they do if they were face to face with their targets. A recent powerful example of this was Gina Miller in conversation with one of her trolls. Which takes us back to the issue of a proximity-based audience. As someone whose done both online and in person teaching, I know what I prefer; that lived, embodied, experience of being there, where one’s senses are triggered and there is the sense also of being able to feel and respond to what happens in that space, and amongst that audience.

Having considered teachers and their employers, and to some extent students (who we might take to be young adults and those older), what of children; how do they value physical proximity? My kids at least, and the vast majority I’ve spoken to or heard about recently, seem desperate to get back to school. The principal reason it seems is that they are missing their friends, and face-timing them is a lesser and degraded expereince. And a good proportion say they’re also missing the opportunity to ask their teachers questions, directly, in the moment. Some of those in power seem to acknowledge these values; the Secretary of State for Education, Gavin Williamson, when pressed on why the youngest children should go back to school first stated: “It’s not just the education but the social interaction”. The cynic might retort that the concern here is nothing to do with this, or the children; rather, it’s to get their parents and carers back working – the old schooling as childcare argument. We might look to the fact that nannies have been allowed back into people’s homes (before anyone else is allowed to enter them) to substantiate this claim; their function is patently to enable people to work, maybe even absolve parents of the work involved in caring and talking (and now teaching) their children. Which takes me to robots. In Japan, for example, robots are now present in the homes of the elderly experiencing social isolation, to provide them with accompaniment. The rationale seems to be that we need something to be in physical proximity with, if perhaps not someone.

What about shopping, one of the few things most of us have been able to do (at least for food)? Behaviour in supermarkets displays values diversity. Consider the self-scanner. Personally, I avoid them as best I can; they seem somehow to add to the dehumanising effect of the supermarket experience. And yet, there appear others who would choose them at every opportunity. The truth is, in some outlets this choice doesn’t even exist; increasingly we find shops without a staff member in sight, as if the Mary Celeste. Is this the way things are going? Similarly we know the number of home deliveries has exploded. But we should remember that some folk have been shopping online for ages. And many others, who have experienced this service for the first time recently, will doubtless be converts, unlikely to go back to ‘proximity-based’ shopping. I guess I shouldn’t moan, at least the outdoor markets are open, places for me that seem to constitute a marriage of shops and theatre.

Maybe there’s something about the distinction between space and place, as geographers so readily point out: a space becomes a place when there’s folk in it, some sort of engagement and relationship with others is implied, some sense of ownership, a shared reason for being present. Of which the football crowd seems an exemplar. How extraordinary that the tentative steps to restart the game, post lockdown, have only gone to show how significant the fans are. Forced to play behind ‘closed doors’, we’ve seen a range interventions designed to replicate them, from images of people placed on the seats, to audio recordings of crowd noise, even putting sex dolls in the stands. However illogical, football, all agree, is nothing without the fans. Fans create a particular kind of ‘atmosphere’, a feeling unimaginable in the virtual world.

A similar case is being made of the Prime Minister; why, some ask, is the government so keen to get parliamentarians back to the House of Commons, despite the rest of the nation being told to ‘socially distance’? The claim is he thrives on physical proximity, seems to need the crowd baying behind his back when at the despatch box. And that he is nought without it – his words lack meaning when independent of that crowd. And that he is oblivious to the fact that some MPs who have been told to observe social isolation guidance due to their health or caring responsibilities will be disenfranchised by this decision. The prize, it seems, of having parliamentarians in the House is that they are exposed to the pressure of the whips, stripped of the protection afforded them by their home-based virtual existences. As criticism mounts, it would be easy to conclude this is mere tyranny. Indeed, there may be more to this story than meets the eye, and revealed to some degree by the on-going Brexit negotiations, which we’re told are making little progress. First, note these negotiations are occurring on-line. Then consider what’s missing when compared with face to face discussions: usually, what’s said around the table is only part of the story – there’s also all that chit chat at break-time, while having a cup of tea. That’s not happening on-line. To some, the absence of these informal interactions may be a good thing; they’re nothing but arm-twisting after all. To others, they may be essential. I wonder then if there is much difference between this form of politics and ‘World Café’, which has grown in popularity as a conference methodology in recent years. Conference evaluations over many years have shown participants value highly the learning they attribute to informal conversations with fellow delegates, which take place between sessions and during breaks and meal times. World Café attempts to replicate this informality, and advance this informal learning. I wonder if this teaches us that there are limits to what we can learn on-line; and that the wider context, the milieu, matters if we are to learn in the fullest sense of the word?

Maybe the subtleties and nuance associated with this idea of learning might help us in our quest for the meaning and value of physical proximity? Maybe physical proximity implies some kind of performance, which is difficult, perhaps impossible, to conceptualise without an audience. Thereafter, physical proximity takes on meaning, and value, only in relational terms; fundamentally it’s about ‘with’. At its best, it is a mutually affirming relationship; ideally, an embodied experience, not virtual. Granted, we have the phenomenon of ‘YouTube sensations’, but how many of those ‘likes’ are from those who would not prefer to be present? So, despite the likelihood that many arts venues, theatres and the like will go down the pan due to the economic impact of COVID19, I fear not for their long-term future; people will demand them back.

What seems to emerge is the idea that we value some things simply because there are others present. We might ask, for example: how many people’s interest in exercise has waned because there’s no longer the option of doing it with others? Not that we need to be active to value physical proximity; simply being with others is important to many – therein the value of human togetherness. I suspect going to the pub is like that; it’s a world away from having a drink at home, especially on your own. As with the arts venues, many pubs will struggle due to COVID19, but, in time, others will be reborn.

I get to a point where I’m pretty confident that what will survive in terms of physical proximity will be that associated with civil society, our informal lives, if you like. This is because, compared with our working lives, we tend to have greater control over them. Generally, we are free to do whatever we want during our leisure time. We can, and will likely, demand opportunities to be in physical proximity with one another. And, no doubt, the market will respond. I’m much less sure about our formal, professional and institutional lives, as we tend to be in less control of them. Others decide. So, pupils and students, for example, may have to put up with what’s offered them. And those paid to work with them may well be expected to shift their work online, whether or not they like the idea. Unlike teaching and many social work activities, my game, community and youth work, and especially detached youth work, may escape, precisely because these are examples of those rare practices that, by definition, have a foot in both camps: they are professional practices deliberately located in civil society. They rely on people’s (whether youth or adult) voluntary association. This is people work in its purest sense; the people decide that they want to participate. It is their choice, a choice they can exert because we are working in their leisure time.

No-one should assume though that the ‘people work’ they are involved in necessitates physical proximity. As the wheels turn, many will find their practice re-framed. Many will feel disenfranchised. The question is whether they will accept this; will they demand their rights to participate in this process of conceptualisation: to repeat, both in terms of meaning and value of people work. Arguments will need to be made, good arguments. When the Secretary of State speaks of the value of social interaction in schools, even if his underlying rationale is economic, can these words be seized and re-framed? Why not speak of social education instead, and the importance of that? That might open the door to discussion of related concepts, and values; where social implies relational, moral, ethical, associational, collaborative, even democratic (all constitutive of the kind of education we would seem to need in the 21st century). And this in turn gets us back, inevitably perhaps, to the kind of issues that seem to underlie so many of these question, they are fundamentally about power, authority and control; about who gets to decide. We should never forget that we have the capacity to frame these values, and the norms that emerge from. Ultimately, without a fight, many practitioners may find that doing things that involve physical proximity with those they work with maybe reduced, and being sociable ends up being what they do in their own time, at their expense. Unless, that is, the case can be made for, what Ridian Brook calls, “the miracle of human presence”?

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *