What a day I’ve had. Like a lot of days, I did a lot of work but didn’t earn a red cent. C’est la vie. Maybe I’m part of the Big Society. Certainly it’s been interesting, and I learnt a lot (by the way, I also learnt recently that to use ‘learned’ in preference to ‘learnt’ follows American parlance) and hopefully this learning will help me in several endeavours, from being, variously, a parent, a school governor, Vice-Chair of the Federation for Detached Youth Work and a part-time PhD student. But, I have to say, a good deal of what I heard today troubled me greatly. So let me try to recount a few of my anxiety-inducing experiences.
First off a meeting at my eldest son’s secondary school for his ‘Review’ session in the presence of his Learning Coach. A Learning Coach I’d been told previously is someone who “tries to persuade rather than tell.” Confused somewhat about the distinction between persuasion and telling I was enlightened in a subsequent discussion with youth workers about the National Citizen Service (something I’ll come back to later). The youth workers weren’t happy, and when I probed why this was they told me it was because they felt they had to “persuade” young people to get involved. Hearing this word again, only a few hours after having heard it in the school context, I couldn’t help but ask what their definition was. “Persuasion is manipulation” was the simplistic but forceful reply. Now we could argue a lot more about the need for a more robust definition, but my point is to illustrate the varying conceptualisations of this term in the education sector. And to illustrate also that this is one of an increasing number of ‘floating concepts’ in our work today. And that words, and their understandings matter enormously, particularly in the context of multi-agency work where folk can often be using the same language but conceiving of very different things.
Back to the review day; my boy’s task was to, as you might imagine, review his progress in school. I’m big on these things, self-reflection, self-evaluation (and their social equivalents) and indeed the wider context in which these activities are located: ‘SLD’, or student-led discussions. I know that might not be fashionable in some circles: take this of late from Dennis Hayes in his criticism of P4C. There are some valid and reasonable points here but I worry greatly about anything that smacks of a return to traditional forms of education (sic.) in which the pupil is little more than a receptacle to be filled by an all-knowing teacher. Rather, as Oakeshott (1962, 1972) states: “Education is both an engagement between teacher and learner and an initiation into the conversation between the generations of mankind.” I digress, albeit, I think, for important reasons, but I figure now it’s the frameworks (rather than the processes themselves) for understanding ‘performance’ that do my head in. The lad has his ‘current grades’ and ‘projected grades’ (which I’m told are synonymous with ‘predicted’ grades: “just semantics”). Strange then that each and every one of his projected grades is where he is now plus two levels. Is this coincidence, arbitrary or based on something more rigorous (as Gove would have it)? This matters, as in my academic endeavours to understand the impact of data systems in education I find a range of realities from deterministic predictions to extraordinary presumptions, apparently based on little or no evidence at all. What then of his teachers’ assessments of his ‘effort & behaviour’ and ‘independent learning’: how reasonable (and based on what criteria) are his A’s, B’s and C’s? And does this matter? I guess so, in which case we have to get beyond ‘how’ (although that would help) to why?
Notwithstanding, it is this (externalised) data that my son employs to review his learning and chart the progress he wants to make; little, it seems, is a product of self-initiated reflection. He talked of “levelling his progress” but when I asked him what this meant he said he didn’t know. In his stead, the Learning Coach suggested this was about “showing where you are; giving it a grade”, which might have been a more accessible way to explain the expectations of the school in the first place, rather than sensitising him to what are clearly alien languages – languages that (in their use) might just have other motives.
Thereafter his SMART targets; you know the stuff: things that are Specific, Measurable, Achievable/Attainable, Realistic/Relevant and Time-related. Again, like so many of the things I’m talking about, I get the gist but I have questions about, and am troubled by, the detail. I thank Gus John in this regard, as he once told me if you can’t work out what’s happening with the whole then consider the details: they’ll give you a good idea of what’s going on, of impact. And some insight into the values that influence such mechanisms. So, to be more precise in my questioning: how can (amongst other things) ‘effort and behaviour’ targets be made specific and, of perhaps greater concern, how can changes be measured? On this, I’ve long-since considered it a reasonable riposte to argue that measurement per se demands a unit; so what units are we talking about here? I note also the spawning of an industry that claims to be able to teach us that everything can be measured, typically using ideas of ‘distance travelled’. But to me they’re unconvincing in their claims of objectivity, as if trying to seduce us with the language of science (what Ray Tallis calls scienticism). Invariably it’s also reductive, and often deterministic, as if that adds validity also. Take this contribution to the World Wide Web:
“Specific: If the target is too vague or too big to be achieved in a reasonable length of time, the student will have difficulty understanding what they have to do.
Measurable: “How will we know if the target has been achieved?” If the answer is, “We don’t know!”, then the target isn’t measurable!
Attainable: The pupil must be able to reach the target; it must be at the right level. If the target is unreachable it will lead to demotivation.
Realistic/Relevant: The target must be achievable in terms of resources available. It must be relevant to the task in hand.
Timed: A time for achieving the target should be set, and a review held when that time is up. All those involved should be aware of the time set and the review date.”
A teenage philosopher could murder that. Rather than nuanced, the value of a good deal of the complexity of the world in which we live ebbs away, bounded (in value) by specificities, measurability, assumptions on capability, and constrained temporalities.
We might consider the so-called ‘scientific method’ here. A process that involves asking a question, developing a hypothesis, undertaking some kind of experiment and observing and recording what happens, and then thinking about (or ‘analysing’) what happened. Oh, and sharing the results (one presumes for the benefit of others). Maybe this provokes self-correction as to what measurement might mean. And maybe then, ironically, it takes us back to broader subjectivities: the kind of things that are intrinsic to the process of evaluation – the definition of which, I try to remember, implies, by virtue of the clue in the word, recourse to values. It’s a process of valuing. Which might assist us in many domains, were we to do justice to a concept wider than measurement, and ask, simply: what’s good, what’s bad, and what needs to change? And if you really need data, record that. And use it as a stimulus for the next enquiry. And so on.
An aside then to my studies: anything more than a cursory glance at the history of data systems in education would surely lead to the conclusion that the primary function of data collection is to enable governability – control by another name. Enough said, for now.
To conclude my thoughts on SLD and pupil reviews; great but let’s have something more nuanced. Why not extend the student-led franchise, such that they can think within the wider range of possibilities that evaluation, rather than measurement, offers?
On to the National Citizen Service Roadshow, an opportunity for potential ‘delivery partners’ to learn about the extraordinary regime that constitutes its procurement, contracting and commissioning arrangements. Back to the framework issue me thinks. For all the talk of flexibility (perhaps the greatest of modern-day floating concepts) a contract, by definition, has to be stipulated, written down. Add into the mix myriad criteria for Payment by Results (PBR) and it’s easy to see that this thing is anti-democratic by design. You have to say what you are going to do before you start and this within a prescribed set of constraints. These, of course, are the ‘outcomes’ to be achieved, the outcomes without which you ain’t gonna get paid. The youth then is a unit to be activated; you’ve got to get them to do what’s wanted in order that the Queen’s shilling is secured (I use this term specifically in the hope it might illustrate something of the process of incorporation that is at work here). Maybe I am naïve here also: following Zizek maybe the reality is there’s no escape? Oh, and perish the thought that an outcome might reasonably be considered that that ‘came out’.
Even this system I get to some degree, but I pointed out that one of the reasons why there appears limited throughput from youth service involvement to NCS participation is precisely because when youth work is good young people come to expect and demand opportunities for participation. Note here a further floating concept; in the first instance participation is simplified to taking part; in the latter its something much more substantive: being involved from the outset, in discussion, negotiation, planning and design. And evaluation. In sum, a process (and a principle) in which decisions that affect people are substantively informed by those people. It’s about young people’s power, or lack of it, as the case may be. Where the youth worker is concerned that they have to ‘persuade’ young people to take part, here’s the rub: they too are predisposed, committed to participatory practice. They’re struggling ethically. And it ain’t happening for them or the well youth-worked youth when the process has had to be itemised in advance (and often in great detail) of any conversations with [those] young people simply because contracting and commissioning demands it. So again, I’m not dissing the aims; after all I spent years working in outdoor and adventure education, and years more encouraging young people to engage with and learn from others (although I am concerned that the promotion of ‘social mixing’ within the NCS model will probably not include interrogation of the forces that have driven social polarisation in the first place – not least the levels of inequality that now make us one of the most unequal countries in the world). Nonetheless, add to that social action and your talking my language. But here also constraining temporalities inhibit anything substantive; you can act socially in a moment but something more profound might just take a little longer. There are references to ‘graduate activities’ and ‘sustainability’ but, once again, the performative behaviours associated with the contract-based culture means few are going to give much regard to what happens after the 3 -4 week programme for which they get paid.
Finally then to my evening’s fun, training for school governors in the implementation of performance-related pay (PRP) for teachers. It might just be me (in fact it was on the night and, frankly, often is elsewhere) but I’m minded to ask if PRP is a good thing, and what the evidence-base is for it, rather than just go headlong into learning about policy implementation. I had requested in advance some references to the evidence base and was told they didn’t exist, “although there is research from business”. But on looking that up you typically get this: “Academic evidence has increasingly mounted indicating that performance-related pay leads to the opposite of the desired outcomes when it is applied to any work involving cognitive rather than physical skill.” On this basis its extraordinary to have to sit there and listen to this stuff as if it’s a done deal, a process in which any doubts you might have are (it is assumed) dispelled by a document entitled: “True or False Exercise” where each of a series of propositions, such as “It’s not possible to pay teachers doing the same job differently without it being an equal pay issue”; or “By allowing schools to reward teachers as they see fit there will be huge inconsistencies in who and what are rewarded” are ascribed definitive answers. Both, if you hadn’t guessed, are identified as false. And yet so much hangs on so many variables and interpretations of [these] floating concepts that it cannot be reasonable to accord these statements (and most of the others) as, simplistically, truths or falsehoods. The fact that they are is testament to the politicisation of these training events and Ofsted in policing the implementation of this policy. I recognised this document actually; at least as an adaption of one produced by the Department of Education entitled “Common Myths”. Whereas this is bad enough, given the points I have made, for the training provider to have added the riders of ‘True’ and ‘False’ is an extraordinary display of incorporation and politicisation also. Ironically, and perhaps the sole redeeming feature of their version pertains to the section “There’s no evidence that performance related pay works as an incentive for teachers / improves outcomes” – it comes with the note “the DfE has not provided us with evidence that absolutely refutes this challenge”. Here we are invited to ‘Discuss’ which seems preferable to ‘True’ or ‘False’, or even its classification as ‘myth’ in the DfE’s own version. Not that discussion is invited anyway. And if my concerns about politicisation are still regarded as wanting, read this: “Schools that fail to use the staff budget to differentiate appropriately between high and low performers could receive adverse judgements from Ofsted”. Something else to add to the slippery activities of the Gove stable?
One would think all this constitutes a pretty poor foundation for a training course but, hey, it’s the law isn’t it, so let’s not bother questioning it and just get on with our duty to implement it. Not that enthusiasm for PRP was lacking. I’d hesitate to wear my geographer’s hat here but this was North Yorkshire (Harrogate to be precise) after all.
We were asked what we hoped we’d get from the session. For me I would like to have been convinced PRP was a good thing and that we could identify reasonable criteria for what good looks like. Which is another way of saying that discussion on PRP might just get us back to the question that there never seems time to ask, never mind time to try and answer: what constitutes a good education? Which has to be the most fundamental question in education ever. Surely, you can’t have criteria if you don’t have the values, aims and objectives that proceed them? Not a chance of any discussion on that either. Makes no wonder I’m going [increasingly] grey. What we are treated to is, yes, you’ve guessed it: more SMART targets; and the assumption again that the world of education is infinitely measurable.
Citing the evidence that performance-based systems lead to perverse performative behaviours (typically the ‘picking of low-hanging fruit’, teaching to the test, and a focus on those pupils that will get you over the line, often to the detriment of those assumed well above it or assumed to have no chance of achieving it) I am countered by those who re-articulate my stance as a slight on teachers’ integrity. No sense that these behaviours might have structural causes and be reasonably ascribed as structural violence. At least the integrity gibe is consistent with the paradigm that this whole story sits within: individualisation. Which makes me appreciate more my learning at the #edufoucault conference (see Twitter feed); there are mirrors everywhere in neoliberalism. One might reflect back the question of integrity to those whose defence is “I’m just doing my job, governor (sic.)”.
Perhaps now we get closer to understanding the ideological influences at work here and the real aims behind all this – that this is little to do with school improvement and more so to do with the desires of ideologues to destroy workplace solidarity (a point Zygmunt Bauman makes forcefully in several of his books). This social, collective, collaborative, cooperative dimension is, in my judgement (and that of many others), precisely the thing that makes for a good school. Ethos is a social concept. Solidarity, and the power of the masses, as Barbara Ehrenreich’s anthropological study of the demise of carnival shows, is considered a threat to the power of elites and must be mitigated at all cost. Forgive again what might be considered a further digression but I’d say it’s the myopia in our own scientific method that seems to inhibit awareness. The lack of appreciation of these social dimensions will make things worse not better. In practice, consider the challenge of attributing effect to an individual’s action. What of the aim to counteract bullying; whilst reasonably evidenced within the institution, you’d be hard pressed to make the necessary linkages to a particular teacher’s targets such that their performance-related pay is triggered.
In conclusion, I’d venture that the prize for the proponents of these regimes is not a better education for our children but, pure and simple, more control. Which only goes to show that the semantics of the age: flexibility, freedom, responsibility, participation etc. are anything but authentic. I’m left, as a half-baked philosopher, with questions of ethics. What of the welfare of the primary client (not a word about them in the NCS or governor debates); what of the question about whether we (as governors) should implement all law – is there anything we might reasonably object to and resist, even if it was the law); what of the ethical dimensions of democracies (where does the power lie)?
Final thoughts: I think there is a wonderful irony that, of my examples, and despite my framework criticisms, it was the prison of the school where a space had been created for a student to have at least some semblance of an opportunity to lead the way. I have said this before, but I’ll say it again: it’s as if (as youth work morphs into youth social work) it and school are like ships passing in the night. The progressive, democratic practices associated with the history of youth work consigned to history, whereas at least a few spaces emerge in at least some schools for something that might well pass for pretty good informal education (albeit that they tend to occur despite, rather than because of, policy).
I’m left also with the realities of discomfiture that I might upset a few folk here, but find also some solace in the words of George Bernard Shaw: “In this world if you do not say a thing in an irritating way you may just as well not say it at all, because people will not trouble themselves about anything that does not trouble them, (as quoted in footnote* by Boff Whalley). Which reminds me of something else that I did that day and that he and I have in common: we’re both fell runners. Boff waxes lyrical about fell running not just as a past-time (as if, only, to pass the time) but also as a recreation; a process by which we can re-create ourselves. Which reminds me also of something I once heard Bauman say: “the time you enjoy wasting is not time wasted”. Perhaps these two perspectives have something in common; autonomy and self-determination. Just as fell running is as free as one can get from oppressive rules and regulatory frameworks (particularly in its non-competitive form) so too we might imagine education as an unbounded space wherein learners have the opportunity to create and experience things rather than merely consume that that has been preordained by others and performance managed into existence whether we like it or not.
0 Comments