The Olympics; what kind of legacy do we really want, and need?

by | Aug 29, 2012 | Philosophy | 0 comments

Much has been written about the Olympics, and doubtless more will be contributed in the future, especially about the much- vaunted ‘legacy’ and whether this comes to pass. Let me weigh in a few thoughts.

I’ve always been optimistic and positive about big projects. They seem to me to be emblematic of the grand narratives that have all but disappeared from contemporary politics; such is the obsession with re-packaging and spinning ‘what the people want’. The grand narrative, by design, implies leadership and conviction, especially in the face of criticism. You have to believe in what you are doing and worry less about what the cynics might say. And get on with it. Furthermore, they’re positive: “vote for me because I am going to do something good”, rather than negative: “vote for me and I’ll protect you from your neighbour”.

To me, hosting the Olympics is the sporting equivalent of, say, building the St. Pancras international rail terminal; somebody had to stick their neck out, say it was possible. And get on with it. You’ve got to respect that. The tangibility of these kinds of projects wows many, if not all. And so they should. And that’s a good thing. But their greater significance is they have a tendency to affect the many rather than the few.

All this should inspire us to think that other (big) things are possible. Neil Armstrong’s passing is poignant. I used to say that the early space programmes, and visiting the moon, were some of the worst things man had ever done, simply because they taught us to think that we could (relatively easily) achieve the seemingly unachievable. I worried that we’d started to believe a wider range of challenges, like combating famine or poverty, were considered just as easily resolvable. It’s as if we’d become complacent about our capabilities, and taken our foot of the gas both in terms of seeking solutions to these challenges and getting on, practically, with doing something about them. I’m a bit more philosophical now; we need these grand narratives and big activities to remind us that such interventions are possible. Hence, I now kind of see these things from a different stand-point – that we should do them, rather than not. But the substantive point remains; do we have the desire to do something about the myriad of big issues that affect the planet and its peoples, the things that affect the many rather than the few?

What then should be the Olympic legacy, and can it be realisable in these terms? And does the rationale for making it happen stack up?

We’re told health inequalities are increasing and that a swathe of the population appears all but immune to the warnings, seduced, it’s intimated, by a celebrity culture where there’s a sense that you don’t have to put in the graft. The messages are clear; think on about the four great evils of smoking, drinking too much, poor diet and sedentary lifestyles. I am most certainly not pointing a finger here – there’s plenty of folk only too happy to do that already. Rather I wanted to question the dominant orthodoxies of how society should respond. Seb Coe’s view that sporting excellence is the key driver of increased participation in sporting activity obviously deserves some respect. Not least because, sport seems to connect all four of these issues, especially if there’s a bit of competition involved (which could just as well be against yourself). Eating well and moderating alcohol tend to go hand-in-hand with being motivated to do well at whatever physical activity one chooses. Basically, we look after ourselves better when we enjoy our sport and want to do well at it. When it comes to smoking, you’d be hard pressed to find more than a handful of celebrity footballers. So smoking’s a no-no when sport is a motivator.

And yet, analysing Coe’s pronouncements, my sense is that they are the sporting equivalent of ‘trickle-down theory’.  And we know what those theories have done for the masses when applied more generally – pretty much nothing; rather they have tended to exacerbate inequalities. So berating folk for not heeding messages, whether they be from public information films or through the subliminal effect of watching our superstars, seems to miss the point. Something more structural is needed; which, as much as it pains me to say it (given the identities we share: Leeds, Yorkshire, fell-running), leads me to take issue with the Brownlees. My pride in their achievements is absolute but I’d happily argue with Alistair given his recent interview responses in which he said he said: “I’m a Conservative. I don’t believe there should be too many rules. There should be lower taxes.” I’d say he was, at best, misguided, and may well have conveniently forgot that taxation paid for the training of his teachers, paid for the facilities he’s used, supported his health care (and employed his parents). And contributed to the Olympics scholarship he received at Leeds University. And will likely support him further given the recently announced (and welcome) funding for elite sport, a significant proportion of which will come from the taxpayer. Will he reject this?

And what of rules; I can’t think of a sport that doesn’t need them, albeit (like Alistair) my exposure to fell running has taught me that we should strive for the minimum, and celebrate the acceptance of risk, given it is mitigated by the solidarity of each looking out for the other. But when it comes to the challenge of rousing the nation’s sedentary masses (whoever they may be) regulating those that pedal rampant consumerism is and will be necessary. Take ‘the sweet you can eat between meals’ and ‘do you want to supersize that?’ culture by way of examples. So ‘the rules’ can take many forms.  Which makes Gove’s linguistic sleight of hand in changing ‘the rules’ on the provision of school playing fields to one where ‘suitable’ will do smack of a decision where ideology has trumped good sense. In short, only a concerted policy agenda, backed by resources, investment and regulation will do. Note also, amongst further examples of the liberalisation of rules, the demise of the Schools Sports Partnerships and threats to the very disability benefits that made participation possible in the first place.

So, when it comes to the structural, structures matter. One of the Olympic tickets I was lucky enough to procure (by gum, I tried to get others – but failed) was for the sprint kayaking at

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *