Two TV programmes which, for me at least, were required viewing just so happened to come back to back this week. The first, Panorama’s expose on public sector pay, with it veritable feast of state-funded ‘fat cats’ was followed immediately afterwards, albeit on a different channel, by John Humphrey’s exploration of what must be the most pressing of issues: the achievement gap in schools and the extent to which it has at its roots social inequality.
Whilst being deeply frustrated by both programmes lack of appetite to chase down a number of prompts about (i) the cultural and structural determinants of this inequality, and (ii) the potential philosophical and methodological turns that would likely improve things, I was intrigued as to the cross-cutting theme; namely, that individuals can make a massive difference.
From council chief executives to school heads and ordinary teachers the message rang out, ‘we need the best’. The debate on school improvement has had a good airing and is riven with complexity but I was struck (perhaps, seduced) by the line “it’s not what school you’re in, but what class you’re in”. Notwithstanding my own caveats on wider determinants, it is an intriguing question to ask: what would happen if we applied the same analysis to community and youth work?
So a flavour of my own notes made while viewing ( – my missus thinks I’m a real sad man, forever watching the telly with pen and paper in hand). They might intimate the kind of traits, values and virtues we want to see in educators, and inform the kind of training and education they need to really make a difference:
‘Good teachers have high aspirations and expectations of young people; they are good communicators, enthusiastic, supportive, and have a desire to be there (both in that space and for young people); they are creative, organised, consistent and determined.’
A final thought, I’ve been trying to help a visiting professor from Japan better understand the UK and wider European youth work scene as she scopes a Japanese youth service [basically, they haven’t got one at the moment and have finally started to think they need one]. I’ve put her on to a number of the great and good (in my opinion at least) and she always emails me back with a few comments about her encounters. So a few comments from her also:
‘These people are warm, hospitable, and considerate; they have a capacity to be human and work in human ways; they are natural and real; they believe everyone can live their lives positively; they are respectful, democratic and trustworthy; they help young people relax and feel free; they demonstrate reliability and are good listeners.’
A different cultural perspective on what matters? Perhaps not, just an age old re-affirmation that what’s important is forever underpinned by good relationships. I can’t help thinking that we’d all be better off if education was a much more human rather than the increasingly instrumental project it appears to be of late.
A few weeks ago I had a stab at exploring at least some of the wider cultural and social determinants I mentioned above. Maybe some programmer can be brave enough to take these on at some point in the future? See here for notes from my presentation to the 1st European convention on the history of youth work and youth policy and the resulting declaration that was an outcome of the week.
0 Comments