Historically, detached youth workers have employed a four-stage model that starts with a period of reconnaissance, prior to contact-making, intervention and development work. ‘Reconnaissance’ (in more recent years also referred to as ‘community profiling’ or simply ‘community research’) is a process of getting to know an area sufficiently well (and the people within it) such that this knowledge helps plan and inform workers’ practice. Reconnaissance seeks to establish the needs of young people through dialogue with them alongside an analysis of a wide range of data such as community attitudes and indices of multiple deprivation.
A generation ago detached workers might get as much as six months to undertake their reconnaissance. Since then the time invested in this process has dwindled to such an extent that many workers now undertake little or no reconnaissance. Workers’ own ‘internal’ research has increasingly been supplanted by data from external sources, such as Violence Reduction Partnerships particularly as these become sources of funding. Generally, this takes the form of geographical ‘hot spot’ data, based on high numbers of incidents of anti-social behaviour, crime and violence in particular areas. There are a number of issues here:
- The absence of ‘internal’ data collection (particularly that gathered through participatory research involving young people) is in conflict with the fundamental defining feature of youth work: that it is ‘youth-led’; the narratives of young people’s ‘Voice and Influence’ and ‘co-design’ have become increasingly tokenistic. This is exacerbated by the dominance of external mechanisms, such as the ‘hot-spotting’ data referred to above. Not only does this undermine the commitment to work with young people (as against doing to) – a long-standing youth work narrative – it also results in a radical re-conceptualisation of youth work (and especially detached youth work) as being premised on crime prevention and violence reduction rather than a form of informal, social and community education.
- Whilst there is an argument that detached youth work can be both, the central question is ‘what is its primary task and who are its primary clients?’ This can be understood in terms of ‘The Question of Needs’, which is actually an enquiry into ‘who should decide what young people’s needs are?’ In many current conceptualisations of detached youth work it is clear that the needs of external agencies now take precedence over those articulated by young people themselves.
- At least some of this demise in reconnaissance practices can be attributed to ‘short-termism’; it is increasingly common that detached youth workers are funded on a short-term basis. Implicitly then they are subjected to both managerial and funder pressures to engage quickly and achieve ‘outcomes’ in often very short periods of time. The decline in local authority youth services (including its complete abandonment in some places) and the prevalence of contracting and commissioning arrangements designed to engage the voluntary and charitable sector in the provision of youth work adds to this short-term and temporary (rather than permanent) culture. We might ask why some professions are implicitly permanent, such as school teachers, social workers, health workers and the police – and why youth work is not accorded this status?
- Coupled with this is increasing anecdotal evidence of workers expressing concerns about their welfare and safety. It is clear that reconnaissance acts as an important protective factor; the knowledge accrued gives workers confidence: they know the community, and the community knows them.
- Beyond these safe-working issues, there is the extraordinarily pragmatic question of effectiveness: workers experiencing anxiety about their safety can be observed to struggle to establish the trust-based relationships accepted by all stakeholders as essential to effective practice and which are particularly important (and hard to secure) in relation to young people experiencing disadvantage and marginalisation who are often vulnerable to exploitation and involvement in harmful behaviours. Indeed, some workers (typically those part-time, new to youth work or with little or no youth work training) increasingly resist making interventions in complex, uncertain and potentially risky situations. Metaphorically and actually, they are more likely to ‘step back’ rather than forward wherein the essential engagement of young people is weakened.
- It is now possible to imagine workers taking out grievances against employers where a reconnaissance period is absent.
- In combination, the lack of commitment to a substantive period of reconnaissance in a great deal of contemporary detached youth work actually undermines the efficacy of practice on several levels. This appears particularly so where it is imagined (conceptualised) as a ‘progressive response to crime’ and hot-spot data led.
- A further reconceptualisation, drawing upon on the wisdom of historical models of detached youth work (that include reconnaissance) is surely needed, especially if the many expectations of the practice are to be secured, including that workers are confident in engaging with challenging situations.
0 Comments