Je suis un économiste: work, housing, milk, youth

by | Jul 24, 2012 | General Youth Work | 0 comments

I’m not an economist, but so what; it seems pretty much anyone can claim to be one these days. A bit like someone who knows a few kids and, when questioned by the press, is identified as a youth worker – regardless of whether it’s their profession or not. In fact, I’m not even sure what economics is; which is probably something else economics has in common with youth work. So, forgive this foray into uncharted territory; if you’re here because you follow my commentary on youth and community work, perhaps there’s something in this for you also?

The best I can fathom is that economics is something to do with the study of financial incentives. That’s something that has come to me in recent weeks, as the government dreams up more and more ways to try to incentivise people to behave in particular ways. It seems behavioural economics is their cup of tea. This includes the old favourite; pay the rich more to motivate them; and pay the poor less in order to do the same. And yet each and every political intervention made seems to spawn a new range of perverse effects, which goes a long way to substantiating my original thesis: no-one’s got much of a clue when it comes to economics, and less still when it comes to appreciating the fall out of economics-based social policy.

Many years ago (the mid to late 80s) I worked on a poorly paid four day a week contract in Tower Hamlets, East London, and went to university one day a week (for which I had to pay). Even though this was a professional contract (based on my existing professional (JNC) qualification) my income wasn’t sufficient to meet my basic outgoings. The system then was that I was able to access housing benefit to help me make up the difference – to make ends meet. I remember well that my meagre flat cost £455 a month. I was told this was the ‘going rate’ and reflected the fact that there was very little property available, even in this less sought after area of London (Hackney). Footnote: things have changed a lot, which makes me shudder to think what a flat would cost now.

Back to economics. The landlords knew well they could charge whatever they wanted. Fast forward to today; little seems to have changed, certainly not the structural issue of there being a limited housing stock. The chronology’s important. Right to Buy was in full swing (without any commitment to reinvest proceeds into new build), and the construction of new public housing had stalled. Plus ça change; today (or at least recently), and according to Ken, Boris presided over the building of only 56 affordable houses in London between April and October last year. Or, if you prefer Boris’s retort, the number was 2240 (although at least half are acknowledged by him to have been built by the private sector and, as such, unsubstantiated as ‘affordable’). Either way, this pales into insignificance compared to the 30,000 properties the National Federation of Housing says is needed.

Thinking about solutions is what’s animated many. Some suggest rent ceilings; regulation is what’s needed, they opine. But wouldn’t it be better to support the supply side, through liberating empty homes (see #emptyhomes on Twitter), building new social housing, enabling people to build their own, and encouraging sharing. Then again, if we think critically, doesn’t this situation say more about income levels? Just as I couldn’t sort out the numbers back then in London, so we find that there are seven million or so people in Britain reasonably defined as the ‘working poor’. Forgive me again, but surely the rhetoric of ‘being better off in work’ is plain rubbish? Hence, we go back to the same old story: many folk simply aren’t getting paid enough.

I’ve learnt from my work in Europe that the surest way of mitigating poverty is through the benefits system. What am I to believe then when my own political leaders tell me the exact opposite; it’s compassionate, they say, for people not to be on benefit? Sure, if they’ve got a job that pays enough to live on. So I say again, wages for many are just too low; and, in fact, decreasing. There are those that will tell you that they are earning as little as half that they did five years; and countless others who haven’t had a pay rise in ages. Perhaps that’s the eternal truth, employers, simply, don’t want to pay. Look at the supermarkets; I wonder how many who work there need their incomes topped up?

Of course many of these employers will say they can’t afford it, but is this where the behavioural responses to the incentives (my definition of economics, remember) come in? Constructing an employment regime based on part-time work looks like simply responding to (or taking advantage of, as the case may be) structural incentives (in this case, the very existence of a benefits system). Which is to say that what’s happening looks like it’s based on the knowledge that the state will pick up the slack. Or at least did. But not now. So can we conclude that wages will rise, as this wage subsidy disappears? I doubt it. Lest we forget that a good deal of folk working part-time would rather work full-time. Locate all this in the recent findings of the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, which illustrate that the average family needs to earn around £37k to have a decent standard of living, and it’s only too plain that things are bad, really bad. And that the current ‘economic’ plan is based on an understanding as far from this reality as can be imagined. What about a living wage?

Finally, I seem to have developed a special interest in the on-going story about the price of milk. Of all the examples you could find of economics, milk seems to be the one that has it all, and says it all. Perhaps it’s because the supermarkets are implicated here also. My sense of reality is that the people of Britain seem to identify milk (at least the liquid kind) as in the same category as housing, health and education; as a basic need. I don’t think I have ever considered its price; such is my sense that it is a necessity. But it’s when you go abroad, where it’s impossible to get ‘our milk’ that you realise how much it is part of our culture. And for those of us who appreciate the Great Outdoors, with its patchwork of farms, we once again realise that this is complex, but important. I figure we are fast approaching the situation where milk will come from overseas mega farms (or perhaps the supermarket’s own), with all the animal welfare implications that entails. Unless, of course, somebody does something, or at least gets a grip on the economics.

For someone who usually writes on social, especially educational, and especially youth issues, the subject of this piece might seem a bit of a departure. But I don’t think so. In fact, and notwithstanding my grave concern about youth unemployment, I’ve become very, very, interested in young people’s experience of work in these difficult times. Unpaid work, through volunteer programmes, internships, and the like, is increasingly common; as is illegal work, and the commendable, but worrying, efforts of young people to try to subsidise their workless families. All up, the new world of work is fraught with uncertainty (a concept I am generally enthusiastic about, but realistic enough to know that the employer’s language of flexible, adaptable, and agile workforces brings only benefits to them, and misery to those who have to work in this way). This is part of a culture in which the expectations of young people are often far beyond that that they signed up for. Which is an extraordinary indictment of how the positive language of ‘raising expectations’ can be so abused. Perhaps you know of similar stories, and are motivated to bear witness? I am trying to get into contact with workers who can help tell this important story. Working with a documentary team, we hope to speak to young people and those working with them. Drop me a line if you’d like to get involved.

Let me conclude by saying that thinking about these issues further confirms that as citizens, as workers, as a society, we have to think deeply about what we really want, what we really need, and how we want to live. And we have to find an economic system that reflects that. And if there is one thing I have worked out about economics it is this: it is not some system, like the Hidden Hand, that we have no control over. Therein the key point, all is political; we have to commit more and more to public debate and democratic activity as, ultimately, we are going to get the kind of world we deserve. One in which people come before profit is possible, and one in which complexity, and values, are factored in and celebrated, rather than left to the simplicity of ‘the market’.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *