Community Philosophy, Philosophy Walks and Citizens’ Juries: exploring different methodologies for discussing climate change.

by | Apr 3, 2023 | Climate Issues, Community Philosophy, Democracy | 0 comments

On a recent philosophy walk a participant introduced himself as being responsible for some of the citizens’ juries designed specifically to discuss climate change. It was clear from what he said that facilitating this process can be a struggle; indeed, he and I have corresponded before about the best methodologies for working with diverse groups. In the case of citizens’ juries, this is usually 30 or so randomly selected people who work together for a total of 30 hours.

To me, community philosophy works really well, given its commitment to encouraging grass roots democracy – a theory and practice influenced by John Dewey. I’ve used Community Philosophy in an extraordinarily wide range of settings. As of around five years ago, it struck me I could combine this with my part-time work in outdoor leadership. Typically, I lead walks in the hills and mountains and run map-reading courses. And so I came up with philosophy walks. Each and every one of these philosophy walks has been a delight, more than anything because it can never be anticipated what kind of conversations we will get into, and working in this ‘uncertainty-appreciative’ way is always interesting. This walk was however to be an exception, at least in terms of the concluding element of the day where we usually arrive back at a pub or cafe and take an hour or so to discuss the day. Often we will create a community of philosophical enquiry where we discuss a question that has emerged during the day. On this occasion I had in mind the group could help inform the citizens’ juries on climate change by tackling the question that is posed to them, namely: “What should we do about climate change?”

What follows is the documentation of this enquiry written up on the basis of the notes I took from what was no more than an hour and a quarter’s deliberation. I am always amazed at how much can be achieved in such a short space of time. So, here we go; potentially, this might help frame the work of all whose aim it is to engage the public in conversations about climate change. See what you think.

Asking questions about questions

Initially we discussed the question itself, and the critical importance of ‘getting the question right’. Methodologically, this requires asking questions about questions, testing the choice of question, especially when the/a question is ‘forced upon us’ (as is the case in the climate change juries). This led to a proposition for the future: two enquiries could take place, in parallel, with participants in each coming together to discuss their conclusions. The first group would engage with the predetermined question and the second an adapted version, a question this group believed was necessary to avoid assumptions (notwithstanding the position some take that climate change is an assumption – which I’ll come to later, as it came up in our dialogue). Therein the two questions:

  • What should we do about climate change?
  • Should we do anything about climate change?

Paying attention to language: questions of meaning and value

Thinking about questions almost inevitably becomes an enquiry into, what I tend to call, ‘the thorny issue of language’. In this case, our discussion moved quickly to a highly unexpected but fascinating exploration of how the pronoun ‘we’ functions in these questions.  Variously, we discussed the assumptions made in relation to the use of the word ‘we’, and tested this by imagining the use of other pronouns. For example, ‘you’ (singular) was viewed by some as demanding, authoritative. Conversely, others thought there might be value in this, as it might encourage greater commitment and accountability. The question of who ‘we’ refers to was identified as particularly pertinent. At this point, our dialogue arrived at a consensus position: that ‘we’ can exert both inclusionary and exclusionary forces, and this needed to be taken into account, engaged with and enquired into. Some said hearing ‘we’ being said brings them into the debate, while others regarded this as presumptive, and made them inclined  to resist the co-option they believed it inferred.

In attempting to elucidate the conversation, others spoke of a widespread concern that some narratives actively foster division, citing the use of ‘us and them’. It was agreed that there was often a lot going on in the choice of pronouns. The group arrived at the conclusion that enquiry-based methodologies must actively consider the implications of using one pronoun in preference to another.

The word – the concept – of ‘community’ was viewed in a similar light; what assumptions are made about who ‘community’ refers to; who is counted in, and who is not? Who is included, and who is excluded? And, fundamentally (in all these examples discussed), who decides?

Philosophy, morality and social action

The group shifted its attention to the word ‘do’, viewing it as a prompt to discuss the kinds of actions that might take place in response to climate change. One participant suggested picking up litter and recycling was pointless when what was really needed was putting a stop to fossil fuel extraction. It was noted that any enquiry into the relative merits of picking up litter versus ceasing fossil fuel extraction also demanded asking ‘who is ‘we’?’ In this respect, posing the question: ‘What should we do about climate change?’ to a community group infers the ‘we’ in question is that group of people – that community. And yet, discussion about the abandonment / ceasing of fossil fuel extraction is likely associated with ‘them’ (as in politicians, people in power) rather than that community. It depends on the type, and scale, of the action under consideration – see later.

Taking action requires motivation. It was noted that (as John Dewey might say) the word ‘should’ ‘does a lot of work’. (Dewey advocates for inquiry into ‘how words work’). The word ‘should’, it was suggested, can be viewed as a flag, a marker, that draws attention to the essentially philosophical character of a statement; ‘should’ indicates moral and ethical terrain, and where moral philosophy can provide stimuli for thinking. ‘Should’, it was observed, can be interpreted as demanding; for some, it equates to ‘must’. ‘Could’ is a whole lot different. The question then became: is this fair; and is there a concern for equality in what might be expected of people?

This took us to moral questions; specifically, a concern for virtues: behaviour consistent with moral standards. Contradictory behaviours were identified as an issue: when a person claims one thing and acts in a manner inconsistent with that claim. The argument was made that politicians and policy makers making these claims have responsibilities as role models. Failure to demonstrate / exhibit these virtues both undermined these claims and invites cynicism. Concerns about ‘vested interests’ were also noted.

Noting that the conclusions drawn can act as a mirror, it was observed that philosophical enquiry is also often subject to cynicism, typically in relation to the process being viewed as detached from action: ‘You’re all talk and no action’. So our central question … ‘what should we do?’ was ascribed greater value as it inferred social action. All felt that this was not an unreasonable challenge, but that philosophical methodologies (like Community Philosophy, on which philosophy walks are based) actively take up this challenge by providing a schema (the inclusion of a specific phase of enquiry designed to explore the possibility of social action) that focuses on the question: ‘on the basis of what we’ve learned, and the conclusions drawn / consensus positions arrived at, what form of action might we / this community take?’

The importance of testing the conclusions drawn

Questions of capacity

In this enquiry, the group noted there was significant complexity in any discussion of climate change; it is important to talk of ‘capacity’ (in the sense of taking action) as it seems clear some people have greater capacity than others – this commentary was seen to connect back to earlier concerns about in/equality. The concept of capacity then was viewed as inextricably linked to power. This took us to a discussion (and a request for examples) about interventions that ‘facilitated’ and ‘enabled’ the exercise of power. Those given were the construction of high-quality public transport systems and subsidies for investment in home-insulation programmes. A consensus emerged about the significance of ‘the social’ in social action and the view that taking action with others is invariably more powerful than taking it alone. And yet there were further, disruptive, and troubling, questions: how do we feel about a/the lack of capacity / power? Do we experience guilt, shame? And is the taking of social action connected to identity, in the sense of: ‘We are what we do’? And well-being, where “participation, activism and connection to other people is helpful”? And might litter-picking actually be relevant and important here too because of this?

Questions of scale

Notwithstanding the argument that ‘we’ (as a community) have power through the voting system (in terms of advancing the climate change agendas of the parties we choose to vote for), it is unlikely that communities will imagine / conceive of themselves as being able to make decisions about large scale issues such as fossil fuel extraction. It was also noted that in the case of the government’s recent decision to open a new coalmine in Cumbria a great deal of community consultation had gone on, and significant numbers had expressed a preference for the project to go ahead. As a thought experiment, the group was encouraged to locate these activities on a spectrum of community empowerment; what kind of decisions, and at what scale, does a community really have the power to influence climate change matters? This led to a contestation of the ‘there’s no point in picking up litter or recycling’ argument, on the basis that to suggest so might actually be disempowering.

Science and philosophy: dealing with paradigmatic problems

In trying to work out where and when communities might have power, it was suggested this might depend on whether the issue in question was scientific or philosophical. Some felt that scientific matters might be better dealt with by scientists, whereas the general public were as entitled and able as any other group to participate in decisions that were more philosophical in character, such as how resources are best spent. With this as a building block, the group critiqued the idea that science and philosophy constitute two different worlds, which rarely talk to one another. Indeed, participants articulated the relatively straightforward desire to be equipped with scientific evidence to inform their philosophical enquiries. A few expressed frustration at being ‘deliberately / actively’ not told about scientific data. And then there’s the question: ‘how do we know that climate-deniers are not right?’ So, we spent some time on theories of truth and questions of validity, which was valued in helping resist, and challenge, polarised positions, which (in this context) may view science and philosophy as immutable, distinct, different, perhaps even separate paradigms incapable of talking to one another. And yet, what scientific questions do not have a philosophical dimension, largely because philosophy explores criteria; when, for example, does what happening constitute a ‘crisis’? And then there is our experience that science changes; which begs the question of what are the (imagined) implications of this process continuing? This might help in thinking through these matters.

Questions of democracy

This took the group to philosophical questions about the efficacy of democracy to deliver climate change solutions and an analysis of the relative merits of different political systems, including authoritarian models, to deliver those solutions. Citizens’ juries are premised on community empowerment, which contrasts with other forms of democracy. The enquiry identified a tension, perhaps conflict, between these different forms of democracy; that is, the distinction between representation and representativeness. Examining the concept of ‘stakeholder’ is important too; does this imply all people having a say? Or just some people having a say? Further tensions became apparent in discussion of the role and value of experts. Scale (again) was identified as an issue: ‘How on earth can we have a massive change without people being involved?’ asked one participant.

Questions of time and temporality

Thoughts turned, relatedly, to the very specific need to enquire into the temporal issues that were (and are so often) raised in discussions about climate change. For example: what are the implications of saying these matters demand urgency? That is (in combining the two) we arrive at questions about the pace of democracy (seen to be slow) and, also, the pace of authoritarian regimes and dictatorships, which, it might be imagined, have the power to act in an instance (albeit they might face resistance from ‘the streets’ – of which there are many recent examples). One participant viewed this as eco-fascism; whereas might view it utopian authoritarianism.

Final remarks

There was never any intention that this, short, enquiry answered the substantive question: ‘what should we do about climate change?’ Rather, its focus was to inform future deliberative work about climate change. Its contribution appears to be that citizens’ juries, or any other form of public engagement / community consultation about climate change, should begin with a process designed to ‘get the question right’. Thereafter, and throughout, it is essential to maintain a critique of the language used; questions of meaning and value should be at the forefront when discussing climate change – as they are in almost all Community Philosophy-based activities. The value of group discussion, on the basis of ‘Thinking Together’, in exploratory and open-minded (rather than entrenched) ways, always reveals its value in practice. Committing to this will always nourish discussion of climate change issues.

Yes, that old adage ‘you’re all talk and no action’ might, again, be a reasonable criticism of this enquiry. But a reasonable pushback is to assert that talk is a form of action, especially when that talk helps a group of people work out what kind of conversations are needed to address the issue of climate change. Going too quickly to discussion of specific actions is likely to lead to impoverished recommendations for change and action precisely because the philosophical commitment to concept analysis and values analysis is missing. Whatever happens, it is important not to close down lines of enquiry. The quote widely attributed to Albert Einstein seems apposite: “If I had an hour to solve a problem I’d spend 55 minutes thinking about the problem and five minutes thinking about solutions.”

Time will tell if our friend and those he is working with have more productive conversations.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *