I’ve had the pleasure of meeting and talking with some fascinating folk recently. In the same week, I met Nils Christie, the eminent criminologist in Oslo (he speaks eloquently on Youtube also), and Danny Dorling, the geographer, in Leeds, where he contributed to a public discussion about inequality, organised by The Leeds Salon. What have these disciplines got to do with Community Philosophy, if anything? Nils, now 85 but still working, described to me his early interest in criminology. Growing up in German-occupied Norway he realised he had not had a single conversation with a German soldier. Later, appalled that many of his countrymen had participated in the torture of prisoners of war in the camps established by the Nazis on Norwegian soil, he resolved to interview those who had been prison guards. Two groups emerged; the first who had committed barbaric acts against the Yugoslavian prisoners, the others who had not. The first, he found, had never spoken to the prisoners. The second group had, often intimately. In his famous paper ‘Seeing the Other’ he theorises that this basic proximity, these basic conversations, humanise relationships and act as a form of violence prevention. Simplistically, we are less likely to be violent towards those we know. Dorling has reached prominence through his work mapping inequalities. He shows that greater income inequality leads to the geographical separation of people. The rich live in different places from the poor. They don’t talk to each other. Dorling observed: “Our thinking is changed by the nature of the society we are in; our thinking gets corrupted. It’s more difficult to think clearly.” Despite this intervention, the debate, as these things tend to do, focussed on economic understandings of inequality and talk of redistribution and the like. Thankfully, Martin O’Neill, a lecturer in moral and political philosophy at the University of York, reminded us of the moral and political dimensions of inequality. On reflection (and doubtless informed by my background as a street-based youth and community worker – where concepts of proximity have a status above all else) it struck me this is one of the roles Community Philosophy plays. It puts people in contact with one another, it encourages them to converse, to challenge and learn from each other, to get to know the Other. In fact, I’ve been working also on the extraordinary benefits of investing in the public realm, in order that people are more likely to talk to each other. An exemplar is New Road in Brighton where concepts of shared space have contributed to better understandings between its users, including street homeless and street drinking populations who report improved social and emotional health through this proximity The challenges are great, especially as we observe changing public attitudes to poverty and welfare, perhaps caused by a lack of proximity. But it’s interesting to conceive of Community Philosophy, given its proximity-based model, as capable of informing pro-social social attitudes and contributing to a society with greater equality, less violence and better health for all. Grand aspirations, but why not; especially as the evidence emerges to show these things are happening?
0 Comments