I like Big Society, it’s my political literacy. In fact, it’s been at the heart of my thinking for more than twenty years. And integral to what I’ve worked for in all that time. The current debate makes me think about where we get our ideas and opinions from. Like many I guess, I didn’t have much of a clue about politics in my formative years. But living in the north-east as a young and impressionable student in the early 80s put me in proximity with many influences. It might sound trite but there was a sense that if you didn’t know which way to turn the strategy was simple: oppose Thatcher.
Today, maybe I, or politics, have moved on; things don’t seem quite that simple anymore. The conservative architects of Big Society quote Ghandi: “We must be the change we want to see in the world.” The rhetoric could just as easily have come from Paulo Freire, whose work has profoundly influenced my and countless other youth and community workers’ imaginations. Even Peter Mandelson, charged in the last election with heading off the Tories’ big ideas, has now come out in favour. In fact its advocates come from all over the place.
So, where to get a steer for one’s opinions this time? My own sense is the model I mentioned from my own youth is still pretty much in evidence; if it comes from this government, it’s not to be trusted. One of the guys I work with thinks some sharp-suited young grads. from a right wing think-tank were tasked with finding a simple antonym for ‘small state’. There might be something in that. For me however I feel an enduring duty of care for these ideas. So, I’m convinced of at least one thing: if someone you don’t trust says something you agree with that doesn’t make it a bad idea. My gripe would be that something akin to Big Society has been around for ages, and that it’s patronising to suggest otherwise. Thereafter, in its present form its still an idea – a classic floating concept, desperate for some meat on the bone.
And that’s where I think there’s real opportunity; being enthusiastic about ideas at least makes conversations possible. And even a bad conversation is better than none. I’m intrigued by the sense that those we might converse with might not have too many answers either. And who opts out; my guess is that many will be Tories, who can’t even stomach the sentiments, never mind what it might mean practically. Society still the word they struggle with. That could be interesting.
Big Society might be radical in this way: breaking the paradigm of centralism and a culture in which we wait to be told by others what ideas mean. At least if we all contribute more to this process of ideas generation any practice that emanates from it will be the better for it. My political literacy exactly.
0 Comments