Great evening last night at Helen Lehan’s new PiPs group in Harrogate. Interesting and thoroughly enjoyable, but was it fun? This was, in fact, the subject of our enquiry. We watched: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hMOQHsWfOB4 in which the construction of ‘piano stairs’ in the Stockholm underground influenced many folk to choose them in preference to the escalator. Subsequently we chose to explore the apparently simple question: “what is fun?” Our conversation ranged from issues of freedom: can we be coerced into having fun? We thought yes, on the basis of experiences we’d had being dragged kicking and screaming into the midst of a ceilidh, or being coerced into going to Disneyland – but finding that if we let ourselves go with the flow there was definitely fun to be had. Likewise, are we on our feet at a football match, singing with the best of them, or pinned to our seats thinking like a nerdy sociologist? Perhaps fun implies not thinking too much? Not much hope for Community Philosophy then? Something also about temporality – the way time is. Is fun related to mindfulness: living in the moment, being in the here and now? We considered novelty, spontaneity, the flash mob. Thinking about the distinction between pleasure and fun was instructive also, in both trying to work out what fun is (does having fun imply having a laugh?) and considering the value we ascribe to Community Philosophy. Or maybe fun means we are not thinking about value; it is something pointless, without purpose, even gratuitous: something that offers relief, an escape, an opportunity to forget others things? There was a strong argument relating to the social, which definitely works for CP but has exceptions (albeit only a few) when having fun. Here we employed a classic test: rather than thinking more about the social, could we imagine situations in which we had had fun but were alone (including not being engaged with a character in a book, or watching Les Dawson on the telly)? There was a profound conclusion that something happens to us as adults that constrains fun, and that children can teach us a thing or two about having fun – and maybe a good deal else besides.On reflection – see I’m at it again – and having had a peak at the video beforehand, I’d harboured a desire to talk about Nudge theory, which is, I guess, what they were trying to do in Stockholm. But I’m glad I’d been able, as in all good philosophical endeavour, to leave that behind and engage with the theme we had chosen as a community. I’m pretty sure it was more fun that way. But allow me a thought on Nudge theory (perhaps fun theory?). The idea that we are bounded (to some extent at least) by irrational decision-making might be true but it locates Nudge firmly in an individual camp. It seems a world away from deliberating with others, as we do in Community Philosophy, on the basis that we might just change our minds and develop new thoughts, and choose different paths. It’s tyrannical to suggest that we have fixed preferences. Where does that leave the concept of education, other than being the consumption of lists? Be afraid then, be very afraid, as talk of ‘neuro-education’ (its logical successor?) becomes as popular among policy makers of all persuasions as Nudge theory has been in recent years. I’d still choose the stairs. By the way, watch out for my ‘Philosophical Walks’ in conjunction with the Yorkshire Dales Outdoors Festival: http://www.yorkshiredalesoutdoorsfestival.com in September.
0 Comments