- There was a relative absence of enquiry into the structural problems that youth workers are facing. And, indeed, the structural pressures being experienced by young people and their families, such as The Cost of Living Crisis. In terms of our response, needs are far out-stripping resources: the ‘graph of doom’ comes to mind.
- It was good that we discussed workers’ interpretation/s of policy agendas and the mediation of these agendas by funders; but there is much more needed to develop a sector-wide critical engagement with policy and how it informs practice. With this in mind, we have to careful about “echoing” policy only when [that] policy is seen as advantageous; it is just as important to be self-reflective – critical: are we echoing problematic policy narratives, perhaps, for fear of losing access to funding regimes? “We don’t want to bite the hand that feeds us.” Likewise, are we (like journalists appear to be doing) ‘self-censoring’ (in our case, in relation to issues / social realities)? Are we actively not ‘speaking truth to power’? Yes, we speak of “convening and lobbying”, “of “holding the government to account”, but is this really happening? Has advocacy become corrupted? Are we influencing / complicit in a race to the bottom, particularly in terms of quality? How about saying that organisations shouldn’t be involved in service delivery if they can’t demonstrate capacity / capabilities at the commissioning stage, perhaps through evidencing the training of staff? Surely, the aim must be (as some organisations have proved possible) to be able to say, where appropriate: “Sorry, that contract isn’t okay.”
- Certainly, there is a disconnect between the mantra of collaboration and a policy regime premised on competition. Does the latter help or is it more to do with an ideologically constructed system of control aka ‘divide and rule’? At best the sector is ‘weakly collaborative’, a point proved years back by The Nuffield Review. Likewise, the demand for ‘innovation’ seems to actively disparage the knowledge and experience generated throughout the history of youth work. What of valuing that?
- In combination, greater courage is needed in the political positioning of youth work, and in the articulation of the vision we so often proclaim. As an example, there is almost unanimity in the desire to see universal services, and yet our narratives often speak more of youth work and targeting. And issue-led work. And crisis-driven work. Let us not forget the proven rationale of ‘targeting through universalism’, and by geography (of disadvantage). As a participant said: “We’ve lost the language of youth work.” Implicitly then, this makes it more difficult to assert professional identities. Therein, many workers suffer from a crisis in identity; identity becomes “fragmented due to youth work being scattered into different spaces” (another quote). Ultimately, this affects the sector’s confidence to challenge the government’s vision of youth work.
- From our voice to Youth Voice. What does it really mean when we speak of ‘Youth Voice’; to what extent does the policy agenda actually encourage, support and advance young people’s participation? Where it’s present (it was noted) it is typically ‘formal’ (think parliaments and fora); informal / non-formal voice is sidelined, often tokenistic or, worse still, simply absent. Likewise, does the narrative of ‘working with young people’ stand up to scrutiny; can it be evidenced? Relatedly, there’s a lack of / need for community development approaches / community-based youth work, whereby youth work also constitutes a form of public education, helping the widest possible audience understand what it is.
- Much was said about COVID, and its effects, especially in terms of young people’s inter-personal / social lives, their marginalisation, and how, for some, this manifests in challenging behaviours, mental health issues and so on (including recently the issue of woeful rates of pupils returning to school, post-lockdown). And the absence of a concerted response to these issues. It’s worth remembering also that youth workers (predominantly detached workers) were given key worker / essential status and celebrated for the work they did in responding to local needs. May this be something to do with the absence of outcomes-prescribed agendas during this time? Given they worked in a community-based, participative way, we might ask: ‘Is there a legacy to speak of?’
- Then there are resource constraints, exacerbated by the lack of joined-up / strategic work. And associated recruitment issues; in many areas, youth workers are predominately part-time, have short-term contracts, and are poorly trained – turnover is high. Worse still, sometimes this work is but one or two evenings a week, with no time for reflection, no time for supervision, and no base to work from, such that monitoring is something done in the car before setting off home. All has a consequence for the quality of provision.
- Think about this in terms of safeguarding, of staff as well as young people; workers are often cast as minority partners, made vulnerable, particularly to manipulation by other more powerful ‘partners’, who would have them believe youth work is something other. Consider this from young people’s perspectives, who experience high staff turnover; they come to doubt our commitment to them. Time and time again, the crux of the matter is conceptual: what is youth work (and who should decide)?
- This affects investment in ‘youth work’: much more needs to be done to generate resources from within communities (in the widest sense of the word). And yet, participants reported frustration at having to “subsidise youth work through undertaking other ‘non-youth work’ work”. In this context, should we celebrate “youth work is now happening in many non-traditional settings”?
- Many funding regimes require very significant resource commitments simply to engage in the bidding process. The bigger players take precedence, those smaller (who simply can’t afford the resources needed to bid – see the thousands of pounds needed to bid into the YIF) are marginalised. Full cost recovery is rare, ‘sustainability’ a pipe dream. It’s almost unheard of that resources exist for research and evaluation. Why? Many organisations fear including these costs, in the belief that asking for too much will diminish their success in securing funding, the funding needed to simply keep their organisations alive. Does this, too, constitute a form of self-harm?
- Without exception, organisations criticise short-term funding, and a lack of flexibility and the “wriggle room” needed to respond to Youth Voice and changing needs. The price? Short-term work (as above) signals to young people a lack of commitment to them; workers fear (consciously and unconsciously) making these commitments. Engagement becomes harder. It is a deeply inefficient model. There’s an extraordinary irony; all stakeholders profess to be interested in ‘what works’ and yet we are so far from securing this.
- Relatedly, if the National Youth Sector Census currently shows twice as much youth work exists in affluent areas, we can infer there is something wrong with the review process. Might it be as simple as smaller organisations in poorer areas simply not having the time / resources to fill in the review? As was predicted. Which speaks to the bureaucratic and form-filling challenges all organisations experience, but which impacts smaller organisations the most.
- What’s needed is a humanising of provider-funder relationships; funders need to be ‘present’ more often, to witness needs, and changing needs; they need to experience the process of youth work (as distinct from having a concern only for ends and the risk / problem-oriented perceptions of youth work that underpin ‘ends’). Therein, a further disconnect: “Funders want things; young people want people.” Note here that our falling in with ends-oriented conceptualisations of youth work might be yet another form of self-harm, as we fail to document the processes, and journeys, and accompanying voices of young people, which lead to those ends.
- Stand Firm. We need to be clear in our understanding of youth work, and to invest in the education of other stakeholders, in order that they all become clear about ‘what youth work is’. Knowledge of history helps. As does speaking of processes, of our ways of working. Explain, communicate an identity. Be clear about what we are, and, impportantly, what we are not. None of this is possible without training and Continuous Professional Development. Workers need opportunities to experience, and become experienced. Research is important, and an internal reflective dialogue, particularly that supported and facilitated by older, wiser, advanced practitioners committed to educating those new to youth work.
0 Comments