The publication of the Ipsos-Mori report, Policing anti-social behaviour: The public perspective, and subsequent media interviews with Sir Denis O’Connor, the Chief Inspector of Constabulary, have been much to the fore this week. But if we thought a corner had been turned, having had a generation of one-sided stories about this issue under New Labour, it seems we were wrong; we are going to be treated to more of the same.
It might be true there are 14m incidents of ASB every year (which, we are told, equates to one every two seconds) but where is the unpacking of these statistics? No-one can deny that crime and disorder exists and that young people are involved in it. But how many of this vast number are reasonably defined? Detached and street-based youth workers in particular attest to the development of a culture where young people’s mere presence on the street is regarded as a problem. A panoply of research reports point to unprecedented levels of intolerance and a demonisation of our youth. Recently, we heard also of complaints made about the noise nuisance generated by primary school pupils at play. Whatever next?
All this, stoked by a politics of fear, extolled by politicians with sterile imaginations. No longer the purveyors of a politics of optimism: vote for me because of the good things I’m going to do; now, in its stead, the best they can come up with is: vote for me, I’ll protect you from your neighbour. It makes no wonder we are living in an era of cultural pessimism. The report seems to agree with this analysis; youth is defined as the primary typology of ASB:
‘Much of this wider frame of reference [of ASB] centred upon younger people, typically teenagers. Whilst some noted this association did not reflect the reality of most teenagers, the term ‘anti-social behaviour’ has, to many, become synonymous with young people generally. This may reflect the fact that the term is relatively new and its portrayal in the media and elsewhere in recent years has largely gone hand-in-hand with young people, notably around ASBOs.’
A female discussion group participant from Maidstone is quoted, perfectly illustrating the point: “I have actually just put ‘young’, because although I am not sure if it is just young people you tend to think it is.”
And yet, contrary to the thrust of conclusions that the police have retreated from the street, those that substantively inhabit the street (typically now only young people and those working with them) report the presence of a significantly increased number of authoritarian and semi-authoritarian actors.
Unfortunately, their intent appears only to want young people to ‘move on’, as part of a wider desire to cleanse our streets of this pariah group of ‘yobs’ and ‘louts’. And now we have a new claim that the street must be ‘reclaimed’. The press love it.
In practice, these actors tell us: ‘Don’t get involved; that’s our job’. The impact on our generalised responsibility for the socialisation of all children and young people, and the consequential development of a cultural orthodoxy that ‘it’s none of my business; someone else will take responsibility’ has been disastrous. Thankfully, the report’s identification of the central issues of ‘vulnerability, empowerment and community’ offers us more profitable areas for enquiry. But the spectre of a reality in which the only people who speak to our children are those paid to do so now appears in the offing. In sum, these adult behaviours have to be a factor in youth incivility – we have taught them through our own. Whose responsibility is this?
Which is why it’s strange that Sir Denis claims there has been a retreat of street-based officialdom. And then there are the contradictions; he believes the Police are putting too much emphasis on relationships: ‘we don’t want the Police to be social workers or youth workers’. Which is a bit odd when in the next breath he says he wants more bobbies on the beat so they can “get to know the kids, get to know the area”. I wonder … what is it to ‘know’?
Local people have some sense of an answer. They value police support in helping to foster positive relations and local cohesion within communities. But those working outside the criminal justice system with young people, youth workers for example, despair at the mountains to be climbed in achieving this. Daily, they are amazed at how often young people express dislike of the police. Why so?
Having followed the recent accounts of relationships between the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) and many younger residents of Belfast’s troubled estates one would have to conclude, in that context at least, there was simply no relationship of any worth to speak of. To the contrary, hatred is the order of the day.
Perhaps there’s some links to be made between these different phenomena? Might the way young people are portrayed, perceived and treated in society have a negative influence on how they see it, their sense of worth and even how, at least some, behave?
When Sir Denis says the police need more information where does he expect it to come from when this backdrop pervades? And we should be mindful that demanding this ‘intelligence’ from informal actors, such as community, youth and social workers, may well degrade their relationships with young people also. Perhaps, as is suggested, both the Police (and the Youth Service) should go back to doing what they do best and cease being forced to act in similar ways in the middle? Which is not to say that there shouldn’t be partnership, rather than these partnerships should not be insisted upon or formalised to such a degree that the meaning of partnership as mutuality is forgotten. Instead it should be forged out of dialogue and a respect for differing professional ethics. The public want and expect this. For youth workers this means always working for the benefit of young people; prescribing their activities too much can put them on the wrong side of this equation: beholden to the needs of vocal adults in the community rather than those of the young people themselves. Something a bit messier and less standardised is needed; ‘flexibility’, if you like.
Sir Denis says ‘stopping the rot means it’s not just about the presence (sic.) of police but the presence of control’, which doesn’t intimate a progressive response. It’s worrying also that he has no confidence in partnership working; ‘the youth side of partnership is not on the case; its poor, patchy, slow off the ground’. How ironic then that we are treated to commentary in the same and related news items from those working with ‘hard to reach’ youth, including the head of Liverpool Lighthouse, which has recently won an award for the impact of their work on ASB – not that crime prevention is there primary aim (as some would have it). Their mantra is that a good education and effective support is what’s needed; crime prevention is a positive spin-off, no more – not the raison d’être. To get these the wrong way round is, fundamentally, part of the problem.
Few in these partnerships would disagree that disorder can be a precursor to crime or that early intervention and prevention (lest we forget the initial rationale of the Peelers) is worthwhile. But what kind of intervention; what kind of prevention? We should start by acknowledging both are floating concepts, desperate for definition. Surely we need to recognise some complexity here? This is a complexity that in reality we understand better now than ever before, on the basis of powerful evidence of the ineffectiveness and counter-productive nature of many of the forms of actions we have dreamt up in recent years. I have argued that these interventions, for example the ASBO, the Dispersal Order, curfews, exclusion orders, CCTV, [Alley] Gating Orders and so on tend to have one thing in common, they are reasonably characterised as anti-social themselves. Concentrating on enforcement to the exclusion of other socio-educational interventions (always the first choice of residents whether youth or adult) will never be productive.
What we need are more pro-social interventions. Let us engage more systematically with those who see public space, the street, as having great potential for being a positive place. From street-based youth workers to city planners, architects and the proponents of ‘Active Design’ there is a wealth of both ideas and practical projects to learn from that show that construction rather than instruction and everyday community development activities are the way forward. If, as has been shown, these interventions reduce stress and enhance feelings of well-being maybe there’s even the prospect that folk will be a bit more chilled about young people in general. A populated street, as switched-on coppers have known for a good while, is both a safer street and a street where crime and ASB is much less prevalent.
Findings from work done using Community Philosophy, especially that of an inter-generational nature, concur with a conclusion of the report. The answers given to who is responsible for tackling ASB changed markedly when the question is asked in a discussion group rather than in an individual telephone interview. Indeed, respondents are much more likely to conclude that collective responsibility is a more appropriate way of increasing levels of respect in society (thereby dealing with ASB) rather than expecting the police to be the only ones capable of sorting things out (which was, overwhelmingly, the answer given by individual respondents). One conclusion stares us in the face; we have to sit down, as a community, and discuss these issues. Talking is a form of action.
But we have to do this properly. Even the laudable theory of ‘Neighbourhood Policing’ can be said to have exacerbated things by narrowing down these conversations. In practice, what ‘the community’ thinks is often articulated by only a tiny number of folk, thereby enhancing the power of a few over the many. We might speculate that ‘Big Society’ could do the same. It is clear then that the police, like most public services, have much to learn about participation; they could help themselves a lot by doing simple things, not least providing feedback to the public they engage with (a point made in the report).
But let’s not give up on community involvement; let’s just make sure it’s based on wider, more representative and truly democratic participation, including that of young people.
This may be easier said than done though, as the report’s own methodological inadequacies and prejudices reveal. How can it be that of the ten discussion groups and 5699 telephone interviewees not one participant was under sixteen, and information regarding calls made to the police by young people were removed on the basis of a process of ‘sample cleaning’? Sounds more like ethnic cleansing to me. Indeed, no less an authority as the UNHCR consider this kind of disregard of requests for help from young people (common also in, amongst others, the ambulance and health services) a flagrant denial of their rights.
So, in response to Sir Dennis’ suggestion that the Police should work to local people’s ‘maps of grief and harm’, I would urge him to consider first which people he had in mind and, thereafter, the wider sense of what ‘grief and harm’ means in the communities he is concerned about.
0 Comments