Of course we need the humanities, but it’s proximity that really changes our attitudes

by | Dec 18, 2010 | Philosophy | 0 comments

I, like Matthew Taylor, have been impressed by Martha Nussbaum’s book Not for Profit: Why Democracy needs the Humanities. I heard Matthew speak eloquently about the RSA’s 21st century enlightenment project in Leeds recently, which echoes some of Nussbaum’s work. Both talk about the value of empathy and how exposure to the humanities is essential in its cultivation. I wholeheartedly agree. Literature in particular draws us in to the stories of others, opening our minds to new ways of thinking – in particular to different ways of being: it triggers empathy. But I wonder if there are limits to this very defensible thesis. I’m thinking about the role that proximity might play. It is no surprise to me that in many of the circles I move in, notably those of detached and street-based youth, community and social workers, this capacity to ‘feel’ what is going on in the lives of others is clearly present. But I am not sure this is because they’ve all read Hamlet. Rather, I suspect, this is a product of proximity to social reality. Indeed, street workers take this further in claiming they are ‘privileged witnesses of social reality’. Unfortunately, their efforts to secure investment for their work have for too long fallen on deaf ears, and naturally this situation has worsened in recent times. But for those who have recognised the power of proximity models in getting close to people in order to work successfully with them (young people in the street, the homeless, those in open drug scenes, and so on) many have realised also that this might be the very same model needed for communicating its virtues and convincing potential funders. So they will try to mediate proximity to these street-based populations and trust to the conversations that ensue. There is theory in this also. Philosophers speak of moral distance; the further away from something the less we are likely to be affected by it. Exposure to a hard-hitting documentary undoubtedly inspires some to moral indignation, maybe even to pick up a cheque-book, but for the majority of others moral distance kicks in, it doesn’t really hit the spot. There is something of the dinner party world in all that. In polite society, when asked what I do, many of my tales of working on the street simply don’t seem to register. Plus ca change. And yet, in all the scenarios here mentioned, and more, proximity does seem to have a special role to play. From a holiday maker caught up in some kind of disaster, to a businessperson or potential funder going out on the street with a detached youth worker to a chance encounter with, say, an asylum seeker in public, empathy can occur. Which only leaves me to applaud Matthew on coming to Leeds to give his lecture; I think he recognises that the RSA has a history of being a bit London-centric, and is trying to do something about it – by embracing a proximity-based model. Maybe we should all get out a little more, and get a little closer?

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *