I have been speculating about the likely impact of government policies in the New Year, in particular the fallout from the impending rise in higher education fees. I’m guessing a market will emerge for courses seen to best equip students for the world of work. But as I have suggested in previous posts, it’s a wider debate to ask what actually constitutes a good education in this day and age. The Times Higher Education Supplement certainly threw a further spanner in this works with its recent article on liberal arts degrees, although its American context was not fully explored (many courses are funded by philanthropists over there). Not that the idea of giving isn’t a key plank of the Big Society thesis. See the recent suggestion that we might be able to donate to charity every time we visit the cash point. But I doubt this will appeal to the millions who have less money in their pockets at the moment. Or the crazed cohort of which I am a proud member – those who treat earning a living as a way to subsidise voluntary activity. As our capacity to earn reduces (such as through local authority moratoria on consultants) so greater efforts will need to be made to bring home the bacon. Volunteering might actually go into reverse as a result.
To return to HE funding; my own first experience was at a then polytechnic in the early Eighties. I failed my second year and was giving my marching orders. But I would never say I didn’t get an education there. For me this was very much a social education. I came into contact with folk the likes of which I had never met before. People of all backgrounds, creeds and colours. And a good deal who weren’t at the poly at all. Not least striking miners at the nearby Monkwearmouth colliery. I have long since argued that anything social inevitably has moral, ethical and political dimensions also. It was certainly the case in the kind of education I received from those who were trying to defend not just their jobs but the lives of entire communities. It is an irony that at least some of my work since graduating at another college, in a totally different field (that of informal and community education), has been in the old pit villages, still ravaged as they are by the impact of policy now thirty or so years hence.
I’m guessing that many students will have less exposure to this diversity of conversations in the future, largely because many will opt to stay at home to keep costs down. Those who become obsessed with their studies as training for work with avoid them also. Inevitably all will be deprived of important, maybe even vital, social learning – not only about ‘stuff’ but also about how to learn socially. Which is a further irony as employers more and more bemoan a ‘qualification not education’ culture and the paucity of candidates who know what it is to work in a team and who can communicate effectively.
I suppose in the end we will have to see what happens. But I’d like to think that someone is looking at the historical context of cutbacks in order that it might forewarn of future social problems. I will remain optimistic, as I have long since realised I need to be; but experience has taught me that there could be some bad stuff also around the corner. I wonder if it will be a happy new year.
0 Comments