Why bin services are a cause for progressives.

by | Jan 30, 2011 | Policy and Politics | 0 comments

Notwithstanding the irony of government ministers peddling localism and, at the same time, meddling in how local authorities should spend their depleted resources, Eric Pickles’ recent concern for bin collections deserves further scrutiny. According to the Guardian, Pickles suggests council failure to protect bin services risks creating an “army of angry middle England”. It seems having your bin emptied is the most visible return the middle classes get for paying their council tax, and they’ll be enraged if this service is subject to cutbacks.

Whilst this may be true, it reveals a more substantive ideological underpinning, one that many a progressive might share. This is the belief that buy-in to the tax system is consolidated when we feel we are getting something back for what we put in. This is precisely why universal benefits work, great swathes of society experience a return. So Pickles’ pronouncements reveal a more subtle truth, that there are those in the coalition who recognise this fact, despite being hell bent on the destruction of anything universal. Child benefit is the classic case in point. This reveals a contradictory philosophy in which the logic of targeting is found wanting, even though we are generally in agreement when someone say “when times are hard, we need to get resources to those who need them most”.

It is also instructive to remember many government policies, not least Big Society, were influenced by Scandinavian models. But I see this as a product of selective evidence-gathering. The very reason Sweden, for example, has a Big Society, is that it has a big state. Similarly, Norway is capable of offering nigh on free child care to the middle classes, a fact that, as Jenni Russell observed at a recent Downing Street summit, “caused David Cameron to gasp.” The Scandinavian models teach us also that the middle classes probably recognise that what they get out is less than they put in; but they don’t object. Deep down they know that spend on services for others makes their life better; society actually means something there.

There is no more starker example of the impact of messing with an already problematic relationship between targeted and universal services than my own game, youth work. Our representatives at the recent HoC Select Committee Inquiry into the future of services for young people did a pretty good job of articulating this, even if it felt like their message was falling on ears deafened by austerity. The point is that good universal services head off the need for targeted, and more expensive, interventions in the future. There is a caveat to this, as Filip Cousee, and indeed myself, have worked hard to draw attention to. And that is, services need to be absolutely committed to low-threshold, accessible practices, without which the marginalised will rarely take up these opportunities in the first place.

In sum, maybe we’d do a better job of working out what Big Society is by thinking more about the Good Society?

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *