From What Works to What Fits

by | Jul 22, 2011 | Policy and Politics | 0 comments

A week ago I had a pop at speaking about a subject that has really got under my skin recently. I’d been invited to speak at the British Educational Research Association (BERA) Youth Studies SIG (special interest group). My presentation, ‘Explaining the difference we make: an eternal paradox?’ had been first stimulated by the outburst (which is what I, at least, took it to be) of Graham Stuart MP, Chair of the Education Select Committee, when presiding over the recent enquiry into services for young people. In a tone that will resonate for a good while to come, he remonstrated to representatives (‘witnesses’) of the Youth Service that: “It does seem an extraordinary failure that you can’t make a better fist at explaining the difference you make”.

My paper considered the ideological underpinnings of such a question: new business management; the idea that we can ‘measure’ everything; and suggested that democratic practices would always inhabit a different paradigm – hence the paradox. I proposed ways of ‘stretching the paradox’ if not solving it.

Certainly this was a tentative intervention based as much on my academic meanderings in the philosophy of education. And yet, if I appeared to lack any confidence in my position, it was affirmed this week as I read Tuesday’s Guardian – page 12 to be precise. A good half was given over to an advert but the space that  remained was crammed with three short articles that seemed to have something in common. The first spoke of a review of the controversial decision to do away with the Education Maintenance Allowance, or EMA. A report into this concluded ministers should have done more to acknowledge the EMA’s impact on participation, attainment and retention, before they decided how to restructure financial support. It seems ministers had simply rounded up the outcome of a study of barriers to participation and concluded the loss of the EMA would not be a substantive deterrent. The study’s author begged to differ. Commenting on this lack of coherency, Sally Hunt, secretary general of the college lecturers’ union, the UCU, accused the government of ‘cherry-picking’ research to drive through its agenda.

Adjacent to this article were tales of another select committee, this time in the Lords, and focussing on science and technology. The much vaunted ‘Nudge’ theories trumpeted by a surfeit of government ministers in relation to public health was deeply flawed, His Lordships argued: “The government has failed to base its policies on scientific evidence; it is not in accordance with that available about changing behaviour.”

The third saw us treated to the stats from a government watchdog on counter terrorism. Of 85,000 travellers randomly stopped at ports and airports, 2,687 were questioned and 466 were detained for up to nine hours. Whilst some were arrested and a few convicted these were for non-terrorism related offences. In fact, not a single person was convicted under the act. We should note also that Asian folk are 42 times more likely to be targeted under these powers.

While I’m on a roll, and because one of my lads reminds me to be just as concerned about animals as people, we might consider the proposals to cull badgers in order to reduce the incidence of bovine TB. The research suggests a cull could actually increase TB.

All coincidental perhaps? What ever happened to a commitment to science-based policies, I wonder? I’m minded by John Pitts’ important paper on Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) in which he concludes “policy decisions are made not on the basis of proven preventive and rehabilitative efficacy but rather constitute a means by which government policy, state services and professional practices can be articulated to achieve politically necessary systemic change”. Pitts’ title seems to sum up the whole debacle: ‘Who Cares What Works?

All in all, it seems a bit rich that the government demands ‘evidence’ when, it seems, they have pretty much made up their mind before anything is presented to them or, at best, simply select that that fits with their ideologies.

Last night I had intended attending a local ‘Politics Café’ debate on the effectiveness (or otherwise) of schools becoming academies. The speaker, it was advertised, was going to ‘examine research that questions the ability of academies and free schools to raise achievement’. Thankfully, I was too exhausted to go.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *