From values to value

by | Sep 21, 2011 | Philosophy | 0 comments

A colleague mailed me recently to express surprise that I had not been mentioned in the report on the submission I penned on behalf of the Federation for Detached Youth Work, I was actually mentioned, albeit only in the form of a foot note. This referred to a provocation I had offered relating to the thorny issue of how youth work should be evaluated. The footnote stated: ‘Graeme Tiffany wrote: “sometimes I think of youth workers as being a bit like vicars; how could you judge if a vicar was doing a good job without asking their parishioners?” [Ev w373]’.

My sense was that it had been interpreted as positing a participative form of evaluation, i.e. one in which young people were substantively involved. Indeed it was. In training workers I have often argued that we should take very seriously young people’s responses to three very simple evaluation based questions: what’s good, what’s bad, what needs to change? Despite their tone, you should know that these came to me on the basis of a good deal of time spent thinking about evaluation. I came to realise that the classic youth work question: ‘what do you want to do?’ really wasn’t a good one. And for this reason: it is a future question. Rather, we should invite exploration of the here and now; it is in the processing of lived experience that we often get to a more reasonable assessment of where we might wish to go. To jump straight to the future is to invite that typical response: ‘I dunno’, which is one that often exacerbates negative stereotypes of young people. In sum, we need time and a stimulus to process our experiences, before the question about the future has resonance. Therein, one of the key roles of youth work. 

But my statement had a second purpose, something that might well have gone over the heads of the great and the good on the Select Committee. This was to draw attention to the actual substance of what we take to be valuable, in an attempt to argue in favour of ‘values’, rather than simply ‘value’. It was a deliberate attempt to challenge the perceived centrality of ‘value for money’.

This week an actual Vicar said this far better than I ever could. These were the words of the Reverend Martin Perry, of the parish in which the tragedy at the Gleision mine in South Wales occurred. When asked what he could do in trying to help the families of those bereaved, he said:

“There are times when it is simply a case of listening. It’s important to allow people to express themselves and to begin to talk about things. It’s about spending time with people, which is just a way of saying: you’re important, you matter”.

I doubt you’d find a youth worker who wouldn’t articulate these sentiments in a statement of values. I’m sure you get my point, and understand then why we speak of the tyranny of this reductive shift to mere ‘value’.

Many of these issues are explored in the submission I mentioned above. Having discussed the Select Committee report at a recent executive committee meeting of the Federation for Detached Youth Work I’ll be penning a response to that also. Watch this space.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *