God Bless Philosophy – but where is it?

by | Apr 17, 2014 | Philosophy | 0 comments

Tales of philosophical activities at the independent Taunton School (The Independent, 17th April 2014) might chime with the cultural demand for a more holistic education, but is this what it seems? The Head, or should I say Headmaster, says: “I’m not just bringing up kids to make more money” – but why does he need the rider “more”, or even the focus on money? Where’s the philosophical enquiry into these values? He continues: “we try to show our students a broader way of looking at life.” Nice again, but the example given relates to the current crisis in Ukraine: “[it’s] not about money [unlike for his students] – it’s about culture, ideals and beliefs”. He’s pretty sure, for a philosopher. Might it have been better as a question? At least there’s some doubt that all this will “maybe” lead to his pupils having “a better impact on the world than they would otherwise have had.” Likewise, no sense of what constitutes ‘better’, perhaps just the extraordinary confidence of the independent sector again? Interesting also that philosophical and religious beliefs are identified as distinct, and implicitly different, without reasons offered. No mention of theology.

How joyous that Saturday is a working day and this is promoted as a template for academies and free schools. Appreciative of the 10 hour school day Rosie Millard would surely love it here. Some sociological analysis of the family might be a better bet than philosophy in this regard.

Moving on, whoever thought ‘Rag’ week was anything, anything at all, about ‘raising and giving’? Is there anything that this lad doesn’t know? He certainly knows the value of a target or two, raising money for charity needs one surely; incentivisation trumps intrinsic motivation any day. Or might that be reasonably problematized too? And glorious also that Personal, Social and Health Education (PSHE) is about making sure kids get “the message”. Is this the kind of philosophy that can be taught by multiple choice. Not a word about dialogue. And yet this sensitisation to a life to be lived on the basis of gaming theory and performativity is sold to us as a perverse counter-cultural activity, when in reality (he’s got me at it too) it equips us only to choose which corner of the cage to sleep in: “I take the kids aside (one wonders where) and tell them that PSHE is an invention made up by the government who have told us it’s something we must teach … but that we can make up our own name for it.” How awfully radical. Calling them lessons says it all. Or maybe not, because the poor bastards know they’re going to be graded – I guess, by criteria determined by his Holiness. Please enlighten us how you grade ‘well-being’ and ‘self-confidence’?

He’s certainly got the parents on side, but they ain’t daft; they know the game too: why else choose this school if it wasn’t to ensure their darlings get ahead? And yes, how many times have I heard that: the plebs have to join the school’s community: no sense that it might be part of that.

And yet, regardless of all this, wisdom clearly resides in the youth. They learn despite what’s happening here, not because of it. They’re off, to far flung lands where the education is cheap, regardless of whether it’s any good or not. So much for philosophy. The analogy of bull’s urine is apt, it smells more like someone taking the piss than anything else.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *