My message to the all-party parliamentary group (APPG) for youth affairs

by | Jun 15, 2018 | Policy and Politics | 0 comments

In asking the question: ‘What is youth work?’, and making explicit reference to ‘stages of development’, it is easy to infer that youth work inhabits a ‘transitional’ phase. Whilst its obvious youth work doesn’t aim to work with adults, the danger is youth work becomes conceived of as having a particular temporality: that it is focused on futures, specifically adulthood. What can be lost is a concern for the present; and the sense that youth work is a lived experience. Put simplistically, young people’s motivation for engaging with youth work relate to this present, and rarely, if ever, on futures. For them, youth work is for today and not for tomorrow. The tension between this temporality and that of policy-makers whose aim it is to see young people become full-functioning adults becomes obvious. This is particularly so when young people are identified as vulnerable and marginalised. Here, the tension is best understood between a view of youth work that seeks to engage with young people’s intrinsic motivations and another that, having labelled them vulnerable and marginalised, is premised on protection, prevention and perhaps even rescue, each of which sits in an externalised paradigm. In practice, this tension is lived out as, frankly, a battle between young people’s intrinsic motivations and policy agendas they may have no comprehension of or desire to engage with. Actually, youth work has long since dealt with this tension through the only means possible: conversation, or more precisely dialogue, about how these, often competing, visions of the world might reach an accommodation. Bridging this gap, through reaching a ‘negotiated position’, is at the heart of good practice.

This takes us to the crux of the matter; if policy dictates that youth work has to achieve a range of pre-specified outcomes and impacts, youth work morphs into a manipulative act. The casualty is engagement. Hereto a critical point: policy so often assumes engagement whenever youth workers are in contact with young people. Such presumptions are naïve at best and fail to appreciate that the broader, and historical, context for youth work is that it takes place in civil society settings. By definition, engagement in such settings demands respect for young people’s intrinsic motivation. Given the street and other public spaces epitomise civil society, street-based youth work becomes then a prism for understanding all youth work. For these practitioners, often also referred to as detached youth workers, failure to respect young people’s views, and any attempt to drive them in a particular direction, will result, quite simply, in them having no-one to work with: young people will walk away. To repeat, engagement cannot be presumed. Responsiveness to where young people ‘are’ (not just physically but also in their minds and in their understanding of their needs) is crucial.

It is no coincidence that this orientation, this conceptualisation of youth work, is democratic and participative in character, and that, for many youth workers ‘youth work’ equates to participation work. That is, democratic values can be seen to be peculiarly and powerfully pragmatic; if you want good engagement, and you aspire to creating the conditions in which young people can learn and develop, acting democratically becomes the most effective way of working. In recognition of the fact that these kinds of experiences, more than any other, have been shown to create the cherished democratically-inclined citizen, policy-makers would do well to sculpt a policy environment that afforded youth workers the flexibility and autonomy they need to get on with such work. The extension of these freedoms to young people, through this kind of youth work, offers the greatest of all possibilities that good outcomes will be secured.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *