The annual event of GCSE results day has always struck me as an odd one, and one that makes me somewhat uncomfortable. As a youth worker, the media images of young people jumping ecstatically in celebration of their success sits uneasily with our experience as a profession; we are more likely to be dealing with lost souls for whom the whole shebang has been horrible. Therein an untold truth; many, many, young people are going to walk away from a decade or more at school with little to show for it in terms of qualifications. And the fact is, by and large, this is a scenario that has been played out for generations.
Recently I’ve been working with a group of more than a hundred 16-19 year-olds, as part of a programme directed at disadvantaged communities. I’ve asked all of the young people questions like “did you enjoy school?” and “who’s planning to go to university”. I can count the affirmative responses on the fingers of one hand. School has not worked for them. But there is a greater casualty – learning. Anything that smacks of school in youth work settings receives the response “it’s like school”; and this always, always, implies something bad. Such experiences of school have a particularly grave outcome; there’s a battle ahead to change attitudes to learning per se. That learning is so readily equated with schooling is part of the problem; when school has been a negative experience it can turn young people off learning wherever they are, and including in myriad non-formal settings. So life can be as tough for youth workers as the young people they are working with.
Another thorny issue is what it takes to succeed. Doubtless there are many who have put in some really hard yakka, and they are to be applauded for that. And yet others, who invested the same, will have less to show for it. Typically, these will be those who have far more on their plate than more supported peers, such as those Looked After. But this is only one side of the coin as teachers, and the wider world of educators, like youth workers, matter – a lot. The support they offer can make a real difference. Many go to extraordinary lengths to help; they are true heroes. However, the wider world of institutional behaviour needs looking at too, and closely. It’s not an exaggeration to say schools are up to every trick in the book in pursuit of good results. All well and good, unless that is there are consequences and casualties. In recent times we’ve found out about a range of perverse behaviours from the likes of St. Olaves, with its exclusionary practices, which we know to have dire consequences (powerfully illustrated in the campaign #EducationNotExclusion); and the increase in parents being told, politely no doubt, that their children may be better off being home-educated. Then there is the rising authoritarianism in schools, evidenced by a range of more subtle measures, like keeping young people in school at lunch-time (what childrens geographers call ‘lock-in policies’), to doing away with lunch altogether (“after all, it’s just a time where anti-social behaviour happens”). And then there’s the euphemism of ‘after-school booster classes’, which, whilst technically voluntary, are, culturally at least, anything but. We might add to this litany of ‘measures’ the manipulation of students’ subject choices and the consequential degradation of the arts. In sum, the drive for success tends to degrade the value of young people’s autonomy (which seems an extraordinary irony as this is surely a fundamental aim of education): school becomes something done to young people, rather than a participatory project, as in ‘working with’. One wonders how many schools would opt for a cattle prod if it was seen to produce better results.
Finally, there’s that the age-old phenomenon of some schools celebrating ‘the system’ on results day, whilst others continue to decry it. Typically, the former are those that have done well; they quickly forget they too were critics. They will have been ‘neoliberalised’, as Stephen Ball, the education sociologist, says. And so the system that disenfranchises so many continues. It is a truism that those who design such systems did well within them; and this creates a blind spot. One can only hope these people learn to engage more with that other world, of the many for whom the experience was different; the system was the problem. If we were to zoom out and consider the experience of all there would be a stark conclusion; schools need to change, and change radically. Some hope comes in the fact that there is an emergent discussion about this, and this is taking hold in the very places responsible for the system itself.
0 Comments