Why I took BSBT money

by | Jun 27, 2019 | Philosophy | 0 comments

I have always tried to be careful about my ethics. The truth is I found it more difficult when I worked for statutory and voluntary organisations than ever I do now, and since I began working on an independent basis. Indeed, I have been criticised for going on (and sometime on) about ethics, on the basis that I, unlike others, have a greater luxury to decide. Certainly, I’m aware there are many who feel their employment status deprives them, to some degree at least, of taking a stand. If the fact that I have had few ethical dilemmas to deal with is anything to go by, I accept this criticism. I think now this may one of the few benefits of a freelance life: it is, theoretically at least, easier to say ‘no’.

So why am I troubled by the recent controversy about Bradford Literature Festival, where several contributors have decided to withdraw. In a nutshell, it’s because I have been in receipt of income from the same source they have so roundly condemned: The Building Stronger Britain Together funding regime. And because these are good people whose causes I support. I’ve reflected hard these last few days; why did I decide otherwise?

My story goes back a good while on this. As a community worker with a deep concern for social justice, I was immediately worried, and cautious, when the original Prevent programme was announced. I paid close attention to how it was rolled out, and to the impact it appeared to have. I went to conferences and kept notes about the perversity of Prevent, for example the children reported for a slip of the tongue. I observed intense debate, especially in Muslim communities, as some groups ‘got on board’, and others chose not to. The tensions, and occasionally the schisms, were clear to see.

As a philosopher I had particular issues with the language; to prevent means to stop, whereas my preference was always for more appreciative narratives. In youth work I’d contest the articulation of young people as problems, a deficit-oriented view of young lives. For sure, I worked with many young people who had problems, but the distinction had to be made clear.

In fact, I’ve tracked the language of youth policy for many years, as this has been a focus of my academic work. And become fascinated by ‘language dualisms’, of which Blair’s “tough on crime, tough on the causes of crime” was an exemplar. I started to see here was a linguistic device that, within the same sentence, was capable of generating applause from both conservatives and liberals alike. Then there is the ‘floating concept’, of which ‘prevention’ is my favourite. I once got into bother as a detached youth worker (someone who does the bulk of their work in the street) for calling out a senior police officer at youth crime prevention panel meeting who suggested: “the way to deal with youth crime is to make sue young people are not on the streets”. That’s me out I job then, I thought. In response, I suggested we might do equally well if we rounded all young people up and put them in prison. And then, somewhat theatrically, ‘remembered’ prison was really expensive, so perhaps we should just kill them all. He didn’t take it well. Shaking, I apologised, saying I was only trying to point out when folk say ‘prevention’ they often think many different things, and these things needed verbalising if we were to make progress, work as a team. By luck I got not a baton but a demand to say where I was: I quoted Aristotle: “a good education is a form of crime prevention.” I still don’t know if this is reasonably attributed to the great philosopher; but I did make my point.

Since then I’ve felt the need to elucidate: the primary aim of education is not to prevent crime, rather crime prevention is a handy by-product of education. Whereas teaching has never had to deal with this expectation, youth work has been significantly pushed in this direction by successive political regimes. Indeed, Ed Miliband once told me to my face that he believed “youth work was the progressive response to crime”. I asked him why I had invested several years in training to be an educator.

What if we were to apply the same logic to ‘counter-extremism’; what if we were to recognise it too as a floating concept? What we might see, indeed, what we have seen, is an extraordinary range of interpretations of what ‘counter’ might mean. I’ve been to the areas where the cameras were put up (and, thankfully, subsequently taken down, such was the outrage). In one place I invited young people to, simply enough, make a map of where they lived. They portrayed a whole range of buildings, streets, and so on, but also social phenomena, like drug use. But there were also dots, dozens of them, that I didn’t understand. Until that is I saw they had incorporated a key, with a single symbol: the dot, and the word ‘camera’. They knew the precise locations of every single one of them. I doubt this will ever leave me, nor the thought: what must it be like living in such a place?

Conversely, I’ve listened to Ted Cantle, a deeply committed and principled man, extol the value of social mixing, and how it can engender an understanding of others that repels the influence of those who seek to propagate hate. I stand by Ted in saying I think this too is a form of counter-extremism. And yet there is, I think, a distinction; an important distinction: in practice, this work takes an appreciative stance; it’s trying to do create and build something, rather than stop or disassemble.

It all depends on interpretation. I remember how Anti-Racist Education (ARE) was interpreted by some colleagues many years ago. Youth clubs were set up for different groups of young people, based on gender, ethnicity and religion. None of which concerned me; I recognised the need for some communities to have their own space. I supported this work, and still do. But what worried me was the lack of a commitment to – also – encourage young people to mix with one another. Which was something I valued highly, not least as I was heavily influenced by the great criminologist Nils Christie, who I had met and shared a wonderful few hours with when visiting Oslo. Christie’s fame stemmed from seminal research into the violence perpetrated on prisoners by Norwegian guards recruited by the Nazis when Norway was under occupation. Some were brutal to the prisoners; others would do everything they could to make life a little more bearable. What Christie found was that the difference in attitude could be linked to the levels of interaction between the prisoners and the guards. Those who perpetrated violence on inmates said very little to them, beyond barking orders. They never engaged in even the briefest of conversations. The others did just that, albeit in limited ways; they’d say hello, enquire as to a person’s welfare. Christie concluded these everyday snippets of engagement engendered a sense of empathy, which, in turn, influenced more protective behaviours. Where contact did not exist, this seemed to validate inhuman acts.

The arrival of ‘Community Cohesion’ was interesting. As Paul Thomas of Huddersfield University has pointed out, the floating nature of this concept allowed multiple interpretations. And many youth workers who had struggled somewhat with ARE were emboldened again to promote social mixing. They went with Community Cohesion, where others were smelling a rat and stepping aside.

Today we might call this ‘constructive ambiguity’, albeit the term has garnered bad of press. And yet I have been a defender, a position born of experience of research into violence prevention.  I could see that policy often had to be written in an ambiguous way, purely to get diverse political interests to sign it off. But that’s not where it ends: policy is cascaded to local authorities and other providers, and interpreted there; first by managers, then more managers, and then ultimately by practitioners, even the people they work with. It can and often does end with a wide range of interpretations in practice – for good, as well as for bad.

I suppose then, even if only in theory, what constitutes ‘counter-extremism’ is the same. And that support for literacy programmes and whatever the hundreds of recipients of BSBT funding have proposed might all, in one way or another, ‘fit the bill’.

I’d say also that even though the Home Office may be conducting ‘due diligence’ on these organisations, they are surely doing the same on the Home Office. Clearly some have said ‘no’, and others who said yes didn’t think too much about it. It’s messy, but what I do think matters is to ask how the policy agendas have been interpreted locally.

Here’s where I do want to stick my neck out; whereas I couldn’t find anything I remotely wished to play ball with (with Prevent), I do read BSBT differently, even though it comes from the same government department. Specifically, I feel okay with the promotion of cohesion; working to increase feelings of tolerance, respect, understanding and empathy for others; and the promotion of critical thinking (CT) skills. In fact, the latter is central to what I do and an interest of mine ever since an old lecturer or mine (now many years ago) said our job as informal and community educators was to help people develop a “bullshit detector”. My, how that seems as important as ever in these days of ‘Fake News’.

So, when asked if I’d help with the CT elements of BSBT work with young people I figured I should give it some serious thought. I proposed the use of material I’d developed as a pioneer of Community Philosophy (the use of philosophical tools in community development work) but also methods I’d learnt in Norway – methods that had been further invested in post-Breivik.

I will not forget Anders Breivik nor will I forget the Norwegian response to the horrors he perpetrated on young people. There was the Prime Minister, speaking to the people of Norway, but also the world, in saying that Breivik’s actions were an attack on democracy. Here I understood this in as a reference to democracy in a Deweyian sense: ordinary people (in this case young people) coming together from all backgrounds to discuss with one another issues they considered important. Norway would, the PM said, invest more and more in the creation of such opportunities, for even more young people to do more and more of the same.

Whilst, frankly, doubting that my own government would have responded in this way (such was the history of our policy-makers preferring prevention in a hard, inhibiting, sense) I resolved to be do my own bit to promote ‘democratic competencies’.

In combination, in practice, this means encouraging people to use philosophical tools in a democratic and participative way: thinking together about questions of meaning and value; asking for, exploring and contesting the reasons behind the opinions we hold; critiquing the taken for granted; and learning to value diversity not necessarily in and of itself but for the multiple stimuli it can offer to help nourish conversation and dialogue. I’ve done lots of this work and highlights have been experiencing people who are so often homogenised by the media express a wide range of opinions. This taught me a lot; I just wish many more, especially white folk, would recognise and realised the same. Then there are people learning that changing your mind is no bad thing, if, that is, the reasons for doing so are reasonable.

I have been happy doing this work and it’s been well received. Not that I am entirely happy. I am not immune to the criticism that BSBT suggests guilt by association with Prevent. But then I wonder if it is reasonable to go further (how far does association go?), to suggest we should abandon engagement with the entirety of the state’s activities perhaps just because one or more of those activities are deeply problematic, or we fear reputational damage. Likewise, whilst I’ve argued that some of the things that schools do in the name of education are awful, I wouldn’t go as far as withdrawing my children from the system. Indeed, I take a positive view of the many teachers I know who recognise these problems but try to mitigate them through commitment to broader educational values. I wouldn’t want them to give up being teachers.

Another context that I inhabit sometimes is as a lecturer and researcher in Higher Education. When I hear about the hundreds of millions of pounds universities receive from repressive regimes, the normalisation of philanthropy as an ‘essential’ part of the funding needed to provide teaching and conduct research, I worry greatly. But then I applaud the principled stance many staff make within those institutions.

Like a lot of things, I don’t know what the answers are or even sometimes what the questions are; I can only try my best to hold up my corner and work in solidarity with others, including those who conclude otherwise. Again, I think the nub of it is to look closely at precisely what’s happening on the ground, under the auspices of whatever programme it is.

Then there is the ‘danger of incorporation’, of contributing to the normalisation of a broader context of control that has, certainly, got deeply problematic elements. I don’t want to give any credence to the bad stuff. I suppose if the state picked up on what I and others are doing and portrayed it in terms differently from those I would wish to articulate, then that would really upset me.

And yet all this pales in significance when I consider the elephant in the room, which has for too long now, been austerity. Its bastard effects are to put pressure on people’s ethics, create dilemmas, and sow division. At least all parties involved in the debate about the Literature Festival agree on that.

So, will I do more of this work in the future? Well, I don’t know, but I will probably do what I’ve done already: scrutinise the agenda as best I can; think very carefully about the words, and the ethical questions; and trust I am not being naive or hoodwinked. I’ll try to focus on what precisely I am doing, without losing sight of the broader context. And I can only hope my Bullshit detector is working well and the same can be said for those I’ve worked with.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *