Recently I attended a public discussion about young people’s ‘eco-anxiety’, a phenomenon – it’s claimed – catalysed by (at least some) teachers fear-mongering about the climate emergency. Given my work, I am only too familiar with the issue of child and adolescent mental health, so I don’t want to decry anyone expressing concern about that. But it does worry me that some of those talking about these things might have ulterior motives, and are intent in deflecting the conversation from what, if anything, we should be doing about this, so-called, ‘climate emergency’. And, pertinently, how this should be taught by teachers and other educators. I say ‘so-called’ as it’s clear there is a swathe of opinion that simply doesn’t buy the idea that there is an ‘emergency’. I am not unsympathetic to this as, in listening to their arguments, many appear not to be denialists but are rather more concerned about the ‘language’ used in the articulation of climate issues.
I don’t doubt words like ‘emergency’ and ‘catastrophe’ conjure up awful thoughts in the minds of many. And (which is the case being made) these can lead to feelings of powerlessness, which I know can be catalysed by a broad range of experiences. This means, in one sense at least, there is nothing particular about the climate crisis, until, that is, it’s suggested our own lives are threatened by this. Who would not be frightened if they thought their own life was in danger?
But who is saying this? Some of those who participated in the public debate suggested teachers (from school to university) were the purveyors of doom. Examples were given of primary school teachers telling the youngest of pupils that it was important not to use aeroplanes, that it was necessary to stop eating meat, even that they needed to write to the factory down the road telling them it was evil to use plastic. I kid you not. Others suggested university syllabi had been manipulated, with a perverse emphasis on anthropogenic climate change.
Let me say here and now, and in so doing echo the words of one panellist: I don’t recognise these descriptions from my experience of what’s going on. To the contrary, as a governor of schools for many years, I’d say discussion of these issues is actually quite limited; most schools are too busy getting on with the curriculum in order to meet performance targets (an issue I’ll return to later).
Of course this is messy; I was inclined to ask these folk if they could provide evidence of these claims, but I doubt that would have been conducive to public discussion, at least at that time. And yet there is, it seems to me, something in this kind of response that charts a way out of what was, and is, becoming (yet another) polarised debate. Surely we can agree that evidence is important? Whilst I recognise that evidence can be contested (there are plenty of ‘deniers’ after all) I’d like to make a different move. If the young (and the rest of us for that matter) were involved in a process of seeking out that evidence – in all it diversity – it would surely create some better foundations for discussion.
The problem with the public discussion of science is that there are far too many folk with limited knowledge of the science. So getting on with learning about it makes absolute sense also. Thereafter, with this model of engagement, we might discuss the interpretation of this science. This reveals, somewhat ironically perhaps, that science doesn’t exist in a vacuum (no pun intended). Rather, it catalyses (ditto) an extraordinary amount of questions for which there are no definitive answers: which many will recognise as the world of philosophy. Part of this process of interpretation is to ask ‘what now?’ Or, more precisely, and with a nod to moral philosophy, what should we do now?
In my experience, arguing about science very often gets you nowhere. Different parties have different understanding of what’s true. But in philosophy, with perhaps the exception of logic, the truth is seen as debatable. Whilst I recognise the distinction between pure philosophy and hermeneutics, let me press home a point about ‘process’. Philosophical endeavour implies enquiry into our conceptualisation of the world, and, of equal importance, that enquiry is a social process. Whilst the philosopher alone in the cave never got anywhere, those who engage with others, in the sense of a ‘community of enquiry’, experience the mutuality of having their ideas challenged and nourished and contributing to that of those others.
If, as I’ve argued before, thinking (especially with others) is a form of action, and evidence-gathering and researching are also forms of action, engaging in dialogue to try to reach consensus becomes an even more profound form of action, then action-oriented education appears to have great value. And what do we know about action? Amongst other things, it is the finest medicine for anxiety. And if anxiety is a normal psychological response to fears and concerns, perhaps then we need to normalise action.
In practice, this implies, frankly, a transformation of pedagogy, in schools and elsewhere, with a greater emphasis on the use of community of enquiry methodologies – with science used as a provocation for these enquiries. If teachers were working in this way they would be doing something all at the public debate agreed upon; they would be facilitating an education that emphasises critical thinking, debate, discussion, and dialogue. And, coincidentally I’d say, protect themselves from accusations of politicisation and indoctrination.
A final step is to build into this process the encouragement and opportunity to take action. I am minded by the simple example of young people planting trees. The science is strong, and diverse (think about learning about the natural world, ecology and the like), but also tangible benefits for air quality, flood and noise prevention acrue. Digging the hole requires agency, effort; it is a creative rather than consumerist act. And this translates into demonstrable improvement in green space and amenity, albeit some of which will be in the future, but reasonably anticipated. And then there’s the simple joy of being outside, being and working with others, and feeling you’ve made a difference. Anxiety subsides, a sense of empowerment pervades: the belief that you can make a difference, however small. Therein an appreciation that people can, and have long since, made a difference. It is the practice of hope.
The issue for me is that all this is a long way from what we routinely see in the name of education at the moment. And yet maybe here is a model, a template, for re-imaging education, whether within formal settings, or without in civil society, one that is critical, creative, caring and collaborative (the 4C’s associated with community of enquiry methodology) – a model that informs, fosters and supports social action. As a representation of the power of the people we might even claim it as democratic. And few would argue against that.
0 Comments