On Tuesday of this week I was again banging my drum for Community Philosophy. I facilitated a Community of Enquiry that decided to explore the question: “When is it acceptable to break the law?” It always surprises me that when folk have the freedom to discuss whatever question they want, some questions come up time and time again, like this one. Perhaps this is an example of one of those ‘eternal’ questions that have bothered philosophical-types from time immemorial. And yet, whilst the questions endure, I find the discussions often have very different character.
In this one, the critical issue for participants seemed to be trust; it wasn’t so much the process of deciding to break the law, or not, that interested them, but their concerns about law makers, and whether they could be trusted to make laws on our behalf.
As the discussion wended its way, questions were posed about the value of participation, and precisely who was making these decisions. I found this intriguing as the suggestion that extending decision-making powers to many more people seemed to constitute a response to the vitriol (a word I choose carefully) expressed by a significant number in the group about the untrustworthy nature of politicians. I’d go as far as saying there was near consensus on this; certainly there was no-one prepared to voice the suggestion that politicians were, indeed, trustworthy. To be precise, I interpreted this push-back as an attempt to mitigate the untrustworthy nature of politicians rather than contest it.
Travelling home, what had happened got me thinking further, and this continued into the next day, including when I was discussing with others the planning of a future conference and how we might create a participatory culture within it. I realised that in community and youth work at least, this principle is often taken as read, but that, in fact, it is relatively absent elsewhere.
Here it came to me that these apparently different experiences of work might be related; that participation might actually be essential to resisting the vilification of politicians. I started to imagine that if these critics were actually part of the decision-making process, if they were within it rather than without, that might make a heap of difference. It might even provoke them to wonder if they actually trusted themselves to take on such a responsibility, and question the concept of trust from a different perspective. Which is to say these arguments seemed premised on being external to, excluded from, these processes; it’s a world of difference when ‘we’ become ‘they’, or ‘us’ ‘them’.
A modest Twitter contribution, and subsequent exchange, followed.
Just two days later David Amess was killed, by a man attending the MP’s constituency surgery.
And, today, I’ve spent hours reading the Sunday papers that, quite rightly, focus on the horrors of what happened, but also what needs to happen next. Therein, pages and pages about, for example, having the police present at these surgeries, or even abandoning the face-to-face nature of them altogether, everything seemingly viewed through the prism of our democracy being under threat.
Of course, the security of elected members deserves the highest priority. But keeping them safe is not the end of the matter; there’s a wider social context, at least intimated by these references to democracy. A few brave souls ventured into more prickly territory, asking if political cultures might be an issue, perhaps even a contributory factor. The sense that politics has become personalised and polarised, de-humanised. And that some, at least, among politicians were front and centre in behaving this way, failing abjectly to take their responsibilities as leaders seriously, setting the worst of examples, in full knowledge that social media will almost inevitably amplify their comments.
Certainly, the Observer editorial suggested so: “This grim act comes amid a toxic shift in our politics.” “Our political discourse has coarsened. There are more who try to win debates by dehumanising opponents and launching ad hominem attacks rather than relying on the strength of their arguments.” And again, the suggestion of a synergy between this culture and that of social media: “Social media platforms reward the adoption of ever more radical positions; this level of polarisation cannot but infect our politics as a result of the threats it produces and the activism it encourages.”
Lindsay Hoyle MP, Speaker of the House of Commons, contributed: “it is that the quality of political discourse has to change.” He goes on to say: “It is a British disease.” Hoyle’s commentary is fused with the provocation that the involvement of many in name-calling is on a continuum with the extreme actions of, as in Amess’s case, a tiny minority.
Alison McGovern MP helps us make progress, in directing our attention not to the outcomes of politics but its processes and practices; indeed, she suggests “politics, correctly practiced, can be the best antidote to cynicism there is.” What then, according to McGovern, does ‘properly’ look like? “Enjoying the company of those we disagree with, seeing their reasons and their values and actually understanding them.” Much seems relatively simple: “making an argument works best when there are people listening.” It’s “not just about rallying those who are in our tribe.” “Think hard about where others are coming from. Empathy, understanding, compassion. These are the skills that make our politics function.”
I wonder if the shift we need is here, or, at least, what this is what is needed to broaden out the discussion; to start thinking about politics as a lived experience, an experience that we all might have, not just occasionally on, typically, poling day, but everyday. Might widening participation in politics then deserve some further thinking about in the light of Amess’s death?
A radical thought experiment could be to imagine his assailant growing up in a radical participatory culture, encouraged by educators (both formal and informal), family and community, from their earliest years to think, explore, discuss, test ideas, and argue with one another, daily experiencing what it’s like to make decisions, reflect on them, and take responsibility for their effect?
A few years ago I considered the Prevent agenda and, whilst criticising much done in its name, tried to imagine it differently. Later I felt the need to defend my involvement in an anti-extremism project, but now what I wrote then seems prescient. To be honest my interest in that programme is little different from what I am interested in and concerned to think through here.
Yet more tokenism isn’t going to cut it; as a school governor I fought for years for the use of participatory pedagogies and a greater respect for Pupil and Student Voice. But the truth is that few school leaders appear to have much interest in these matters, where asking pupils what colour they want the toilet doors is as good as is gets in terms of participation.
We might return then to the philosopher’s interest in meanings and values; if participation means those affected by decisions have a right to be involved in the making of decisions; and democracy, from it etymological roots, literally means the power of the people, then we surely have a long, long way to go. And yet, as with the challenges posed by climate change, it seems that the challenge of securing a fully-functioning, inclusive, safe and secure democracy is best responded to the sooner the better, and we ought not to be naïve about the need for radicalism, albeit in terms far removed from the perjorative concept that tends to take precedence in the language of politics.
0 Comments