The recent announcement from UNESCO that Liverpool would be stripped of its World Heritage status was widely reported, with varying attitudes expressed about the decision made. These ranged from it being a harsh decision to many simply asking: ‘who cares?’ Others, including Liverpool City Council’s spokesperson, seemed to suggest this was yet more ‘Johnny Foreigner’ stuff – folk who didn’t really know the city sounding off without having visited in years. How many though took the time to examine the detail of UNESCO’s pronouncement; how many were aware that Liverpool’s Maritime Mercantile City had been awarded the accolade in 2004 only to have been put on the ‘in danger’ list as far back as 2012 because of concerns about the deleterious effects of development in the area? The decision then had been on the cards for years, and yet little, if anything, was been done to prevent the site becoming only the third ever in the world to be delisted since the programme began with the 1972 Convention on the protection of the world’s cultural and natural heritage. Note also, of the 1121 properties world-wide, the UK’s 31 listed sites is likely to be further reduced in number as Stonehenge may be next, given the plans to create a tunnel extraordinarily close to the ancient site. It becomes clear that the government has actively disengaged from its responsibility to conserve the country’s historic assets, which makes its recent concern for alleged corruption in Liverpool all the more pathetic – it’s okay to destroy our heritage, provided you do it legally.
Back in ‘The Pool’, the principal architects of the demise in respect for the city’s heritage appear to be a number of high profile property developers who have long since viewed the status negatively, as little more than a constraint to development. It appears now they have been aided and abetted by multiple power brokers in the City Council, some with such passion that (allegedly) they have waived plans through without proper planning consent and at the behest of those prepared to offer more than a few back-handers. In contrast, lovers of the city’s heritage have been left saddened, but may well have taken their eye of the ball, having felt the status was secure when Liverpool was crowned European Capital of Culture in 2008.
It seems then that rather than being a poisoned chalice UNESCO status has become more of a touchstone for values, and is perhaps emblematic of the wider contestation of values in society. The question is whether heritage is something to be valued at all, or merely a hindrance to development and ‘progress’; and it soon morphs, crudely put, into ‘what is the real business of a city?’, and whether having your own Shard is essential to demonstrating ‘having made it’. Changing the question to ‘what is a good city?’ may be more enligtening, even if the only thing we learn is that there are many different and potentially conflicting answers to this questions.
There are echoes here of what philosophers call a ‘floating concept’, where a multiplicity of views often lies dormant precisely because we tend to assume that when we use a word our understanding of that word – the meaning we give to it – is shared by those we are talking to, and likewise the value/s ascribed to that word.
Of course, there are many floating concepts but closer to home (for me, professionally, that is) the concept of ‘youth work’, which seems to epitomise the point I am trying to make. Recently a friend and colleague forwarded me Radnorshire Police’s tweet about a PCSO and youth worker on a ‘joint patrol’. What’s intimated is a particular understanding of not only what youth work is but also how the practice is valued. Which affirms how important philosophy is, a discipline that – simply put – actively enquires into these questions of meaning and value and one that reminds us of the very real need to discuss these matters with others, without which the assumptions I spoke about will undoubtedly persist.
In this case, we might note that ‘patrol’ most often means ‘an expedition to keep watch over an area, especially by guards or police’, which has obvious militaristic overtones. This reminds me of a presentation I attended some years ago where Ed Miliband described youthwork as “the progressive response to crime”. Mindful that there were many present who may not have thought too deeply about what youth work is, I asked him to imagine why I had bothered getting three university degrees in education. Some may say I was simply trying to get a rise, but no, the philosopher in me judges it, well, essential that there’s some kind of dialogue about meaning and value, at the very least an exploration, as the philosopher of education Richard Pring puts it, as to ‘how words work’.
The essence of this story is the capture – the apparent uncontested incorporation – of youth work into a preventative paradigm and specifically one related to crime. Which, in turn, reminds me of my work with Dynamo International, the global network of social street workers and, specifically, the statement made in Dynamo’s training guide: ‘Street work and communication with media’ (p. 11):
“Police prevention of criminal behaviour has nothing to do with socio-educational prevention work on the streets. Too often a floating message, the term ‘prevention’ is adapted to all kinds of contexts. It is therefore unsurprising to find real confusion and a difficulty in grasping a proper understanding of the work of street workers.”
It becomes abundantly clear how crucial dialogue is, especially in a world where the value of ‘partnership-working’ is also assumed (I’ll resist the temptation to argue this is a floating concept too). Likewise, with wider ‘stakeholders’ (like the police) who so often seem to conceptualise and value the practice of youth work in ways different from the principal actors: the youth workers themselves – and indeed the young people they work with. That said, if I had a pound for ever different view I’ve heard from youth workers as to what youth work is I’d be a rich man. Which suggests too few youth workers are doing the heavy lifting needed to be able to articulate confidently and with clarity what they are doing and why. Being able to do this as a service is a further challenge; coherency, consistency, and consensus demands collaboration: as philosophy teaches us, enquiry into meanings and values is a social process – we cannot do it alone.
Let me try now to suggest a link between the practice of youth work and a way forward. I’m thinking of the fact that detached youth workers walk, where walking is the means by which they take services to where young people are. Frederic Gros, in his A Philosophy of Walking remarks on Thoreau’s account of a new economics, which he came to imagine during frequent walks in the forest. He asks:
“What profit is obtained from a long forest walk? None. Nothing saleable is produced, no social service is rendered, which needs to be rewarded. In that respect, walking is thoroughly useless and sterile. In traditional economic terms it is time wasted, frittered away, dead time in which no wealth is produced. Nevertheless the benefit to me, to my life, is immense. In the end, walking has been more beneficial for being less profitable.”
I’m left wondering whether discussions about the development of Liverpool considered the distinction between profit and benefit, and if simialr thinking occurs routinely at a governmental level when it comes to national policy-making, including about youth work. A progressive way forward may well be to invert this typically top-down thinking, instead drawing upon youth work’s historical commitment to participation and democracy. If the wider population – young people included – rather than a select few were encouraged to take part in a more inclusive dialogue about the fundamental philosophical questions of meaning and value, whether it be about our cities, youth work, or anything else, we might find decision-making is all the better for it.
0 Comments